ScientistIn my opinion, the kind of questions you suggest are just as likely, if not more, to make a naïve, honest townie look guilty and make a deceptive, thoughtful scum look innocent as they are to work properly.
See, I don't think is necessarily the case, but I'm not going to hold it dogmatically. Let's look back on this on Day 2 or 3 and see whether any of these questions turned out to be useful or telling.
At the same time, it is beneficial for town to lynch on day 1 because it gives us a lot more to go on, so as far as your question goes, I would have to say that I wouldn't tie up the vote, and pray my read was faulty.
It's interesting that you say this. I just realised that we've played together just over a year ago. In that game you were town lynched day 1, I was the cop and
I tried to tie the vote because I pretty damn sure you couldn't be scum because you were playing too suicidally. You were lynched, I was night killed and the game was later won by scum. Did I make the wrong call then?
MOWEHmm... this is a hard one. What I think is scummy is someone not scumhunting, or doing as little as possible while trying to seem like they're doing something.
OK. I'll be asking you about who's done the least scumhunting at the end of the day.
Imperial GuardsmanNQT, you are the Good. Do you side with the Union or Confederates?
Given that if the Ugly dies, the Good essentially becomes a Unionist, it would make sense for them to side with the Union.
I note that you asked me this question
here. I overlooked it (because it was in a huge undifferentiated bolded block). I post afterwards
here, answering a whole bunch of people but not you. Yet you enter into the thread again
here, but you don't pull me up on the missed question. OK. I get that playing mafia is strongly performative: some people are better at juggling lots of different conversations than others. And even then, it's difficult to get right all the time. But it seems like you're just going through the motions. Can you give an explanation for your play so far?