@Tiruin: I agree with your points re: misleading opening text. You're right, we don't even know what we're voting for.
Webadict: What percentage of teenagers are evil?I questioned it right here. This was before you posted.
You claim that you figured all of this out before anyone else did, but that just isn't true. You were the first one to actively voice it, certainly. I had already come to the conclusion you had and dismissed it as too simple. I questioned NQT's "confirmed town" status because I believed something to be up, but given the fact that the mod had been ambiguous on damn near everything, I decided to hold back until I had more information. You, on the other hand, went ahead and posted what you suspected. You seem to be missing the "slightly-bastard" part of the description: this isn't full-on bastard mod, even though both of us and probably several others have been looking at it that way.
Ok, you can take credit if you like. I don't particularly care. I think part of the difficulty of the setup is that attacking a confirmed townie head-on requires a player to take a huge risk - I think it's fair to say that NQT would probably have glided along without any real suspicion for a good while if I hadn't called him out.
I think you're wrong about "semi-bastard", incidentally. Webadict defines what he means by semi-bastard in the OP - a bastard game in which the moderator does not lie to you. We know he can't mean "a regular mafia game with some funky roles/ flavour puzzles", because nobody (other than NQT who is lying) seems to know their win con. That alone makes it a full bastard game.
Does Anyone Actually Have A Wincon?
I don't, but I'm pretty sure you do. You were calling yourself a Confirmed Townie earlier, right? How can you say that if you don't know your wincon?
I am evil and didn't summon the meteor as I said earlier.
Which one?
The meteor one, although I'd be ok with you giving us tips for any other impending apocalypses too.Because of, quite frankly, Occam's Razor. The simplest answer is likely the right one. NQT is confirmed not-evil, therefore, confirmed town.
Only in that case we'd expect him to be actually confirmed town. Not confirmed to not be an unspecified alignment. Your Occam's Razor fails because there has to be a reason for the vagueness.
You keep saying "You clearly don't understand a bastard game", but it is YOU who is being willfully ignorant. This isn't a bastard game like the ones you mentioned, this is a slightly bastard game. The odds of a slightly bastard game having as contrived of a puzzle as you hypothesize is rather, in my opinion, low. You keep trying to over-inflate the issue, but really, you're treating this like it's larger than it is, or you're scum going for an easy town lynch. Use Occam's Razor again, and odds are you're scum.
It's not slightly bastard. webadict said "semi", and then defined "semi-bastard" as "a game where the mod doesn't lie to you". Also I think someone else probably fed you this argument because it's a complete 180 from your previous post.
Also lol at the idea that NQT is an "easy town lynch". Because so many people are rushing to agree with me.
Way to let that get to your head. I don't know you, but I'd suspicious of anyone that wants to advertise themselves. Your reputation doesn't mean jack to me.
It answers your question about why I'd want to make this accusation day one.
Um, where do you get this theory from?
NQT says to vote for the bad guys, webadict objects to the idea. Although as Tiruin said NQT never actually specified what we'd be voting for anyway.