Here's a challenge for the collective hive-mind here: recommend me a game based on my current desktop game icon list!
Ohhh, at first I thought you wanted us to tell you which of those to play. Dang, this is trickier.
Well uh, have you played Dragon's Dogma? It's kinda old in game terms but there's no other like it.
Kind of like your typical fantasy setting mixed with a goofy kung-fu adventure flick, complete with a wide variety of themes and a delightful lack of internal logic. Also, it's very deep - not just because I didn't finish it, but the amount of different playstyles one can use is quite impressive. You can just sword and/or board the heck out of everything and bring a healer pawn along to keep you battle-ready, or you can hire a bunch of mooks and do the sorcerous backup yourself.
Magicians also get to hover at higher levels, which is pretty neat.
It was re-released on PC a couple years or so back, so maybe they improved some stuff like companion AI. They bloody better not have touched the voice-acting, though: it ran the gamut from really dang good to ridiculously hammy, but it was all entertaining and went towards the overall sum of this wonderfully weird game.
I should really dig out my PS3 sometime (well, turn it on - it's right there next to the PS4) and play this again. But then again, I've only just recently managed to clear my mind of the various earworms such as the greetings from the goddamn blacksmith or that ridiculous travelling merchant... come to think of it, I can still hear the words "you'll never hit them swinging blindly!" if I put my mind to it.
It's great, though. Much recommend.
Also I can honestly recommend Hunt: Showdown. As I've said before, it's not really the sort of thing I'd usually play and I almost didn't look twice at it, but it is actually fantastic. It's nothing like a battle royale in my opinion, even if different teams or solo players compete for overlapping objectives.
The metagame is pretty cool, too, with you recruiting, equipping and levelling hunters that can die permanently if things go south. Don't worry though, they can retire.