Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Hapah]

Deathsword: Yeah, your neck on the line. At least someone is voting you now. Nobody has any evidence because nobody has done a goddamn thing. If Lurking was an Olympic event, this thread would take the gold.

Ties are good for scum! And I'll quit hitting the "You didn't extend!" button when you quit hitting the "You didn't scumhunt!" button.

And Geen is noob as hell, we both know it. There's no way he's scum.

And yeah, I am interested in lynching someone. Aren't you? I'll even take a probable mislynch if I have to, but I'm not letting this go to a no-lynch.

[Hapah]

borno, because any lynch is better than no lynch. Would still prefer DS. I'll try to be back.

[Phantom of The Library]

The end drew near.

Attention all Players, the votes currently
stand as follows

[Hapah] {0}:
[Deathsword] {1}: Hapah
[Boltur] {2}: Deathsword, borno
[Geen] {0}:
[blackmagechill] {0}:
[borno] {3}: Jim Groovester, boltur, Hapah
[Jim Groovester] {0}:

Not voting {4}: Geen, blackmagechill
Replacement queue {1}:  wsoxfan

3:00 hours remain.
Day 2 will end Monday ~7:30 PM CDT
Current extension requests: Two. Three requests needed to extend the day.

We have someone in the replacement queue now, but we could always use more! Please post in the thread or PM me if you'd like to sign up!

The LurkerTracker is a wondrous thing: Tracker for this thread

I've mod-extended the day by two and a half hours as I won't be able to write anything until then.

[Geen]

I vote borno. Just re-read the whole thread, my scumdar is tingling. Seems a bit paranoid about accusations, I suspect scum.

RE: Question: Yeah, it's a bit different from what I'm used to, a bit harder because there's no facial expression or tell in text, but I think I can handle it. I guess I've been a bit lurky with my observation.

[Teneb]

Hapah: So, let me get this straight: First you say borno is misguided town, and now you vote him? Way to be scum.

Also, I won't stop calling people out on not scum-hunting because that is the only way to reliably catch scum, instead of just sitting there being passive and doing hipocrytical votes. Like you just did, right now.

You also say you'd love to lynch me, yet you made no real effort to. You are instead going for the easylynch, made even easier by Geen gleefuly jumping on without even caring to give a half-decent justification.

Speaking of Geen, how can you be so sure he isn't noobscum if he hasn't even answered your questions. Being a complete noob doesn't exclude one from being scum.

And no lynch can be better for the town than a near-confirmed mislynch. You are way too eager to lynch people. Even in the last BM you kept claiming that Mislynch > No Lynch.

Geen: Do you mind giving actual reasons on your vote on borno? And you mind answering all the questions asked at you?

BMC: Seriously, one post in the whole day? I know you replaced Dusty quite late in the day, but still.

[Hapah]

I was going for a lynch. I don't think Boltur is scum, and there was only one other person with 2 votes. I'm not really convinced that borno is scum instead of misguided, but we need to lynch.

[blackmagechill]

I was going for a lynch. I don't think Boltur is scum, and there was only one other person with 2 votes. I'm not really convinced that borno is scum instead of misguided, but we need to lynch.

You aren't supposed to aim for a lunch you're supposed to aim for a scum lynch. You're awfully eager to switch your vote to the bandwagon instead of the supposedly ever so scummy death sword. I feel like borno is resting on some pretty shitty and in some cases entirely hidden arguments, sure, but I'd like to know what he has to say to defend himself.
extend[\b]. This was a late PFP, so I'd like to get a better look at this tomorrow.

[Phantom of The Library]

The timers slowly counted downwards. Then, just as they were about to reach zero, the first two digits jumped up to forty eight.

The message came seconds later.

I am very disappointed in you,
what kind of Game is it if the
Players lose their nerve and
don't play?

I'm going to give you another
48 hours.

And you'd better use it.

The day has been extended until Wednesday, ~10 PM CDT.

[Jim Groovester]

I'm going to give you another
48 hours.

Blugh. Thanks, BMC.

I vote borno. Just re-read the whole thread, my scumdar is tingling. Seems a bit paranoid about accusations, I suspect scum.

RE: Question: Yeah, it's a bit different from what I'm used to, a bit harder because there's no facial expression or tell in text, but I think I can handle it. I guess I've been a bit lurky with my observation.

Part of me telling you to reread the thread is that you should pick up on the sort of scumhunting that passes for par. I.E., somewhat lengthy, detailed posts.

Your count total for somewhat lengthy, detailed posts: 0.

You can start with your reasons for your vote. And make them good. And you might make an effort to ask some people some questions instead of spending your time answering them.

And Geen is noob as hell, we both know it. There's no way he's scum.

Experience has taught me otherwise.

Why say this? He can be nooby as hell and scum. To outright exclude the possibility that he's scum based on his noobishness is naive at best, scummy at worst.

You aren't supposed to aim for a lunch you're supposed to aim for a scum lynch. You're awfully eager to switch your vote to the bandwagon instead of the supposedly ever so scummy death sword. I feel like borno is resting on some pretty shitty and in some cases entirely hidden arguments, sure, but I'd like to know what he has to say to defend himself.
extend[\b]. This was a late PFP, so I'd like to get a better look at this tomorrow.

He's right, though. Any lynch is better than a no lynch, especially in role-light games like this. If the day's nearing an end and there's a tie, it's better for you to break the tie even if you'd rather be lynching someone else, as long as the target you chose is somewhere high on your scum list.

[borno]

Sorry guys, I have barely enough time to do one mafia, let alone two. I think I should request replacement and let the next person come in my place.

[Hapah]

Jim: Sure it's a little naive, but I just don't see him as scum. What's your read on him (Geen)?

Two more days, huh? Deathsword.

[wsoxfan]

Replacement #1 ready as needed.

[Hapah]

PotL should let you know if you're in or not, but I imagine you will be. I'd suggest reading what's been posted so far (and maybe another BM game, if you find the time) to get ready!

[Teneb]

Unvote. Hapah.

Hapah, you keep claiming I am scum, yet your only accusation is related to that extend. You tried to lynch an individual you thought was town. You were passive for most of both days. You are doing something that is dangerously close to buddying with Geen, to the point he joined your vote with only the justification that he had "re-read" the thread.

I think I may have been at bit overzealous with my scumhunting when it came to Boltur. As he said, I tried to find evidence to fit my theory, not a theory that fit my evidence. Through D1, you (Hapah) mostly just sat back while others applied most of the pressure on KF, doing the same now on D2 when I attacked Boltur. Judging from that question-less vote back in the start of the game, you look like you have been trying to get me lynched since the start.

Well scum, what do you have to say now?


_{Nice last second save, BMC.}

[Geen]

Bah! Sorry if I suck at this, I'm used to just relying on seeing through bluffs. Also, I answered the questions a few pages back, and I just answered the other one!
I didn't vote for him because Hapah did! I'm just too lazy to quote anything . I'll re-read again and post in an hour or so with some quotes.