Summary: mislynch a townie, then kill five more and win for the scum. I say five because the scum are almost guaranteed to be using their kills.
"Kills"? Mafia tend to get one group kill. I think this is what you call a scumslip, Mr Serial Killer.
In any case, if you use your ability, no, neither the mafia nor any serial killers such as yourself will be able to kill, because you'll just need to look at whose action is missing, then lynch them (example: let's say that webadict decided to go against the plan and kill. You'd just look at the list and see that his "Make targets immune to blocks, redirects and randomizations" is missing from the list. Then we lynch him).
If the user of the oneshot doesn't have anyone who is obvscum in their mind, they're probably going to hit town. If any of them are scum, they're going to use it on the town anyway.
The town.
Will decide.
Who gets killed.
In advance.
Yes? Understood? Read what I just said again in case it didn't sink in. They are as likely to hit town as the lynch is. What we have been given is effectively 4 day one lynches before the mafia has a chance to off the good players. Even if we miss, at least we got those mislynches out of the way without the mafia getting a chance to snipe the towniest person in the night.
The mafia one-shoots would shoot town... UNLESS we tell them who they have to shoot in advance. In that case if we choose scum they can either kill their partner or get lynched for not killing their partner.
Your plan included none of these, and it was a horrible plan. Feel free to come up with a better one while you get lynched.
That was just one element of the plan, idiot. The whole point of a massclaim is that you make an overall plan.
I don't know how to respond to this. BSER - Paranormal is not an easy comparison to make; there are far too many differences between the two. To name a couple:
Paranormal's roles are listed in the main topic.
Think isn't Mephansteras.
That comparison was not the main part of the argument. The main part was that it would be TOO DAMN POWERFUL AND EASY TO USE AS A TOWNIE.
There was no room for misinterpretation at all. I specifically claimed that I'd see the action and the target. You're also stating a blatant falsehood. Scum can kill in the night I use it.
Scum can kill, but you would
immediately know who it was (since everyone has a night action and you have a list of all the night actions performed, just see whose night action isn't on the list and they were the one killing).
But in any case there's no point in lynching you today because, whatever your alignment, you claiming this has completely locked the mafia down for tonight. Heck, if you die sometime I could even use your ability again to leave the mafia completely helpless for another night.
Hey there buddy. Did you really think that'd get me off your back, scum? See, I know that you already knew that I was town. You stated it right here. From your point of view, how is it impossible that I'm fakeclaiming scum? You've been avoiding my bandwagon ever since I claimed, probably to distance yourself from my mislynch.
I didn't say you were town in that quote. In fact, I think you're probably scum. But your claim means that scum can't kill, regardless of your alignment (since you'll have to use your ability tonight, and you won't be able to lie about the result of your ability without clashing with someone), so there's no point in lynching you today.
Hence why I underlined "There's no point in lynching you today."
There's always a point in lynching scum. That's how town wins. Since he stated that there's no point in lynching me, he knows I am town. He then throws in,"Whatever your alignment" to buddy me and make it look like he doesn't know, and complains about me locking down the mafia.
My god.
You are SO UNBELIEVABLY STUPID. That fact is pretty undeniable whatever your alignment too.
I'm saying that there's no point in lynching you
today. Because if you're scum you'll have to honestly use your ability if we make a plan (I have a feeling this is why you're against making a plan) and thus lockdown the scumteam.
Tomorrow? Yes, we can lynch your scummy ass to hell then. But not today.