Nuke:You realise that this is Not The Way It's Done, right? You can't ignore someone just because they aren't playing the same way as you.
Breaking off from irrelevant, timewasting issues is a time-honored strategy. Breaking away from issues that prevent the person in question from "playing" beyond a very, very flexible definition of the word is downright expected.
Also, do you really, really, really expect me to keep on like this on D2? Do you truly underestimate my capability so that you think I do this out of ignorance or plain stupidity?
You like stupid, worthless plans, and don't seem that fond of scumhunting. So yes, and yes.
Cool list of suspicions, bro. You wonder why I'm both done discussing your plan and thinking you might look good in a noose?
No. That list of suspicions seems perfectly valid to me. You will have to explain your problem with it.
You suspect Imiknorris for using too many question marks, claim to be utterly unable to read webadict, and then suspect some people for not contributing enough and don't suspect others.
That's not a list of suspicions. That's a report card plus Imiknorris uses too many question marks.
Sorry, my mistake. I didn't mean accusations. Just... things. Your refusal to respond to things. You know what I mean.
I could respond to them, but then I'd have to lynch you for not doing anything. I'd rather not trap you like that.
...Keep saying something and it will become true. Wait, no it won't.
I have demanded more content from the lurkers. I have berated Iminknorris for his deal. I will concede that I don't know how to deal with webadict (today, at least. If he still lives tomorrow, I will put more effort into analysing him).
I have pressure;
Nobody panics if they're not going to get lynched, especially not the scum, so your scumhunting is going to be 100% fruitless on all but the worst scum.
Ahahahahahaha... no. This is plain false. The scum (and everyone else) is not merely concerned with immediate survival. Public opinion of them matters to them. Check out the scumchat from any game. Odds are quite good that you will find someone mentioning concern at a town comment which is disconcertingly accurate, even if said comment is mentioned as a minor thing with no vote attached.
If scum thinks that they have been pegged, and that their pegger is quite certain for legitimate reasons, they will panic. Even the best will have a brief moment of internal panic- and even the best cannot fully disguise this panic.
Reasons to fear suspicion as well as imminent death: Investigations, vig kills, roleblocks, lynches on future days, increased scrutiny (leading to more suspicion), a fear of ubermenschen with psychic powers (seriously- when people get things totally right, that in itself is scary).
I am not dead-set on doing nothing. I have done more than many others already.
It has already come true.You've asked for more content from half the players in the game. Calling this "demanding" is laughable, and isn't going to accomplish anything when it's that spread out. I might as well say
Everyone: Try to find scum more, okay? and then call that content.
You've questioned Imiknorris some, yes. I'm still not seeing primary suspect level anything, though.
You do not have pressure.
Most scum comments mentioning "concern" at any accidentally accurate town commentary will be the same "concern" town feels about isolated, probably-nothing scumtells. They'll point it out and mention that they don't like it, but they won't panic or stress or start desperately thrashing to get out from under it unless it's something serious. That means a serious, plausible accusation from a credible, focused attacker, not just an offhand comment from someone who's real attention is elsewhere.
As for panicking when that is the case, you're right that that doesn't necessarily need a vote on it to cause panic. It still needs something, however, or else it's just shadows and breeze. Since you're not really being taken as a credible source and are absolutely insistent on not killing anyone until you've had plenty of time to cool off and get distracted elsewhere, I find it hard to believe anyone would outright panic at anything you have to say. Be concerned, maybe, but panic? No.
Also, I find it hilarious that Mr. We Can't Possibly Lynch Scum D1 is now convinced that even the best of scum can't hide their cold terror when called out on being scum.
Investigations, roleblocks, etc. are a concern no matter what. Claiming that being hollowly suspected today is going to cause panic because of the potentially increased chance of trouble tonight is laughable. Trouble on later days is likewise stupid, because they've got no reason to believe it'll be any worse than it was today.
Finally, you feel you're outperforming several lurkers. Cool. Are any of them people you don't currently suspect for their lack of content?
I am advocating a No Lynch. I have stated multiple times that I do not trust my own judgement on D1 suspicions. I am not going to abandon this stance just because people have a problem with it, and as such, no, I will not be voting for anyone, unless truly exceptional circumstances arise (such as my own imminent death, as I am not scum and I know my death would be a waste)
Question: What makes D1 special? Shouldn't we nolynch D1, lynch D2, then nolynch D3 to give our suspicions another chance to cool off?
Also, cool excuse to jump ship on what feeble suspicions you do have come D2.
-Night actions and the results thereof may provide additional information.
See, shit like this is what makes me think you're retarded. "Don't lynch D1 guys, a cop might get lucky! Or a roleblock will give us enough WIFOM to choose the right glass! Seriously, don't waste a townie lynching D1 when we can hope for night answers to rain from the sky!"
I think everyone has terrible judgement D1. Can you honestly say that you have a history of pegging scum D1 reliably?
I don't have a history of pegging scum reliably on any day. What's your point?