Ah. Firstly,
Extend. Six hours left in the day, not enough time for everyone to speak their piece, I fear.
Nuke, your case against Simple is complete and utter shit.
Lets analyse that statement, shall we?
He quite plainly was talking about it being unlikely that there's a literal SK
A literal SK is a SK. SKs are pretty simple things.
To be clear, when Simple said 'literal SK', I assumed he meant: someone who has the Wincon 'kill everyone'
which you twisted and said he denied the possibility of an SK role.
And he didn't? A literal SK is a SK. Last games SKs were literal SKs. They had twists, yes, but their core was, litterally, SKs.
When he pointed this out
He didn't point this out. He backtracked, and started talking about how all threats would be supernatural.
You claimed that 'you wouldn't put it past LNCP to throw in an actual guy with a knife'.
Thus, you have 'absolute confidence' in Simple being an SK because of something LNCP might have thrown in the game.
No. I have absolute confidence because of his reaction. I had base suspicions because of his background.
My saying that LNCP might throw in a 'guy with a knife' is a counterpoint to his suggestion that LNCP wouldn't.
See, like this:
I have a case;
Simple suggests that my case is invalid because X (where X is natural-SKs being implausible)
I show that X is not true, restoring my cases validity.
My original case remains.
Go hang, you fuck.
Dariush.
I don't get it. Why do you do this, every single game? Do you really not see that you are Meta-tunnelling me?
You don't have a case against me. Or rather, your case is 'your case against Simple has flaws'. That would not be a sufficient reason to vote someone, even if it was true.
Please, Dariush. I'm asking you, from the bottom of my heart, to stop being such a dick.
Nuke: Why do you think Simple is SK specifically as opposed to mafia (witch)?
Well, my case is based on his flavour, which to me does not suggest witch. My theory is that he has a grudge against the inquisition. For him to go so far as to join the witches to fulfil this grudge seems unlikely. Possible, yes. But I think it is far more likely that he is acting alone.
It makes you look lazy, at least.
Ah, you got me. Yeah, it was me being lazy.
It is hard (time-consuming, but not impossible) to bring into words all the various things that are wrong with Simple's arguments, but just reading them makes me facepalm at their stupidity. I assumed that others would have a similar reaction.
However, as I said, if you do not understand the obvious flaws in Simple's posts, please, ask, and I will explain them.
No, I'm voting him because he's such a stupid fucking idiot as he always is.
...
:/