Yeah, I mean going into D3 I thought you (Shark) were certainly town, but when you were balls to the wall about hanging Shoes and not being analytical about who could be lying or godfather, etc. ... that's what definately roused my suspicion. If you had played D3/D4 like you had D1/D2 ... I might have been pretty screwed. And, of course, Remalle's late D2 actions were making me think he had to be scum.
I caught that you didn't see Remalle's fakeclaim, but I thought that all but confirmed you were a godfather to me. You couldn't kill me, because you'd have a cop and a cleared townie, and since you didn't think that Andrew was being protected, you had to have had a reason for shooting Remalle instead, which led me to think that you didn't care if a cop was still alive, because you'd come up as town anyway. I didn't even really consider you might have been a roleblocker at all. Which, come to think of it, makes me realize what Andrew's RVS-like question D4 was about.
And, speaking of Andrew, when you posted your result that Shark came up as town, I very much exclaimed outloud "Well ... fuck. That makes my job so much harder." I wonder if I would have stepped up as much as I did if you had said you were roleblocked instead. But even if the ICs think it was a bad idea, I can see your reasoning behind what you did, and perhaps I haven't been giving you enough credit
It was certainly a ... ballsy game, with a lot of faking going on =P I have to admit that even I toyed around with the idea of fakeclaiming doctor D4 so as to try and make certain Andrew was on my side, but I didn't think I could pull it off, and since there was no way to 100% prove what I was saying it either would have not benefitted me at all or even hurt me in the end.