What the hell?
Andrew425, why did you claim Shark was town when you were roleblocked?
Remalle, your doctor claim worked out wonderfully, but it was an incredibly risky move that could have horrendously backfired on you. There's very rarely any good reason for town to fakeclaim, and especially in a limited role setup like this the consequences can be very terrible. Consider if there had been a Doctor in the game who hadn't claimed for whatever reason. He spots your fakeclaim and counterclaims, and because we're good ICs we tell you that in situations where there are two claims for a role there can only be one instance of it stands to reason that one of the claimants will be scum. This limits the choice of the day's lynch to you or the Doctor and since it was lylo and you are both town the game essentially is over right at that point. No amount of pleading that you were trying to catch the nightkill by fakeclaiming Doctor would have saved you or the town from losing.
While I will applaud you for being bold and trying out a gambit (which was really cool don't get me wrong), you probably should avoid doing anything like that in the future. (Naturally, once you reach a point where you're confident you can play with riskier tactics you can do it to your hearts' content, though once you reach that point I doubt you'll really want to.)
Also, a note about Day 4 when there was three players and one claimed cop: Generally, role results are helpful in finding scum but since a lot of the time there will be roles that will screw with these role results you don't want to exclusively rely on them. The main thrust of this is that you should always be scumhunting. If you can't rely on a Cop's results, like you couldn't at Day 4 because of the possibility of a Godfather, then don't; make up for it by doing good scumhunting. Even if you can rely on a Cop's results, you should still never stop scumhunting.
Anyway, good job, town. Since I've been involved, I don't think the town has ever won without a lot of help from the ICs, so you can feel pretty good about that. If you have any questions about your play I'll answer them.