Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ShoesandHats]

Dsarker

First of all, townies don't know who roleblocked them. I probably read the rules a bit more than you. Anyways, how do you think you would investigate the mafia if you were a cop?

[Remalle]

Remalle
If you were the doctor how would you pick a target to save?

Whoever's bleeding more
Randomly on the first night, unless for whatever reason I believe someone to be a power role, in which case I would save them.
Sorry my post isn't better.  The Simpsons is on right now.  I'll be back in a little bit.

[Jim Groovester]

So what does the godfather do? Just look like a townie? Does he get the other mafia stuff?

It's in the rules.

Randomly on the first night, unless for whatever reason I believe someone to be a power role, in which case I would save them.

What reasons would make you think somebody would have a power role?

[Dsarker]

Dsarker

First of all, townies don't know who roleblocked them. I probably read the rules a bit more than you. Anyways, how do you think you would investigate the mafia if you were a cop?

I was referring to the roleblocker then knowing who the mafia was, not the roleblocked.

Pick at random from those I have suspicions about.

[Dsarker]

So what does the godfather do? Just look like a townie? Does he get the other mafia stuff?

It's in the rules.

So he doesn't get a vote? Rules only say that he looks like a townie, not that he, for example, gets to join in with the mafia and decide who to kill. So does he, or does he not?

[Jim Groovester]

Roles provide additional benefits than what a normal player has.

Every player has a vote, every player can post in the main thread, only the two scum can talk in scumchat where they make decisions about what to do and who to kill. The only additional benefit of being a Godfather over a normal Mafioso is that the Godfather will appear town to Cop inspects.

Any other questions?

[Dsarker]

Okay, so the godfather and roleblocker are the two scum, not additional to them?

[Caz]

Andrew425
 No idea, I don't know any of you guys. Dsarker maybe but only because his/her avatar has mesmerised me a few times already.

So we just vote for someone random this round?

Remalle. Are you mafia? (And is that even an acceptable question?  )

[Jim Groovester]

Okay, so the godfather and roleblocker are the two scum, not additional to them?

Those are the two possible roles the scum could have.

They could have two Mafiosos. They could have one Mafioso and one Roleblocker. They could have one Mafioso and one Godfather. They could have one Roleblocker and one Godfather.

And those are the only possible combinations the scum team could have.

Remalle. Are you mafia? (And is that even an acceptable question?  )

For a bunch of new players, yeah, but don't expect outstanding results from it.

[Andrew425]

drakon136

If you were the doctor, in what circumstances would you find it a good idea to reveal yourself?

[Dsarker]

Oh, okay.

[Remalle]

Randomly on the first night, unless for whatever reason I believe someone to be a power role, in which case I would save them.

What reasons would make you think somebody would have a power role?

Well, if they leaned on somebody who turned out to be mafia they might be the cop, or if they outright state it and nobody contradicts them.  Obviously that's nowhere close to being sure, but it's something.  Of course, if I and everyone else was sure someone had a power role, I might protect someone random just on the basis the mafia would assume I protect the power role, if that makes sense.  By the way, is it legal for a doctor to protect themself?  Because that would probably be a better thing to do than random protection.

Remalle. Are you mafia? (And is that even an acceptable question?  )

...no.  On both counts. 

[Jim Groovester]

By the way, is it legal for a doctor to protect themself?

No.

[Caz]

...no.  On both counts. 

If you're a doctor/cop etc, it's advantageous to use your ability every night, right?  Does it protect scum also?

[Remalle]

Hmm... lessee... ok, Shoes, let's say you have to choose between blowing up a bus full of school kids, nuns, and puppies, or else shoot your mafia partner.  What do you do?