Well, let's see...
If you had been correct about the roleblock/nightkill scenario, why would you assume that both the mafia and the SK would hit town?
Mmf. Honestly, I don't know how to answer this. There are so many things I
could say, but they'd likely be more made-up shit and I don't want to do that again.
What about the actual vig (who would have to exist in your scenario)?
In what scenario? I stated facts, my role and what happened to me on night one when I tried to inspect Andrew. A vigilante doesn't have to exist in the scenarios that result from this; there could just be two scum left and an SK. There could also be a town roleblocker, a scum, and an SK. Hence why I was so confused.
It is entirely possible that two killers could try to kill the same person, considering that three out of five living players would have kills, and if one of the two people killed in that case was scum, town would still be able to win.
True, but you aren't considering all the possible situations.
-Why did you choose to target Andrew? He had a rather large "Vig Me" sign on his back, so if there was a vig (or a SK who wanted to pose as one), then investigating Andrew would have been a waste of a night action.
This is how I felt. His 'accusation that wasn't an accusation' of Musicalcakes made him really suspicious in my mind. I wanted to be sure.
A "Vig Me" sign basically means that he looks really, really scummy. Why wouldn't I be inspecting him?
Finally, how the hell was I supposed to know any of that on night one?
Orangebottle, are you sure that you were roleblocked, or did your investigation simply return nothing because andrew died? This might be a really dumb question but I don't know how roleblocking works.
Absolutely. The return PM clearly stated, in bold letters,
You have been roleblocked. The flavor was something about extremely strong whiskey mysteriously appearing next to my bedroll.
My question is why orange is roleclaiming. If he's telling the truth and we lynch someone else/no lynch, he's probably going to be killed by scum anyway. If he lives through the night, it'll be highly questionable, unless because of doctors or something.
My actions prior to the claim were extremely scummy. It's hard to predict what the scum will do when we have no idea who they are(and no real suspects besides me), and even then it would be a flimsy meta argument. Then, if we're wrong, the
actual scum would use this to generate more WIFOM.