Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Andrew425]

Well thank you for the advice.

I was just struggling with the idea that people can actually write down things that indicate if they are scummy or not. So I extrapolated a bit

[Simple]

Yay, we're back to full:
Orangebottle is replacing Noodlerex

[Urist_McArathos]

Oppose Shorten

Just because someone claims scum doesn't mean we can't hunt for their partner in the meanwhile.

I'm going to have to reread this before I can make a case on the second scum; posting from my phone atm.

[Orangebottle]

Diakron. Do I really need to list my reasons for voting obvscum?


Andrew: I don't like how you were trying to save diakron back there. It's like you were subtly trying to either call musicalcakes scum or protect your scumbuddy.

Either way, you definitely need to be in a beginner's game or two.


I'm going to be rereading a few times and forming some more opinions.

[Simple]

Day 1

Votecount:
-Urist_McArathos:
-Jim Groovester: Diakron
-Orangebottle:
-Urist Imiknorris:
-Andrew425:
-NativeForeigner:
-Diakron: Jim Groovester, musicalcakes, NativeForeigner , Urist_McArathos , Andrew425 , Urist Imiknorris , Shark,Orangebottle
-Shark:
-musicalcakes:

Not Voting : --

Day ends Thursday 8PM GMT ( 2 hours !)

[Urist Imiknorris]

Andrew: I don't like how you were trying to save diakron back there. It's like you were subtly trying to either call musicalcakes scum or protect your scumbuddy.

There was nothing subtle about it.

[Simple]

Day 1 End:

After a short and heated debate you decide Diakron must be one of the thieves. "Damn you all! This was meant to be a new start, not the end!" he shouts and tries to run into the dark tunnels. But the gun is already in the Shark hands and Diakron dead body drops on the ground with a hole in the head. You quickly search his body for anything that could confirm your suspicions. It seems your choice was right one as you find a torn scrap of paper with crudely drawn mine map and a knife on him!
You throw the knife into the nearest shaft and look at the map. There's big x on it in one of the distant tunnels but without the other half of it you would need to search these mines for ages. You are too tired to carry on with the investigation so you go to sleep with the hope that tomorrow the second thief will be found.

Diakron, Mafioso was lynched!

It's now Night, it will end Friday 8 PM GMT.
Remember to send in your actions.

[Simple]

Day 2

"You are woken up to the horrible stench of the diakron body but's it's not what make you feel uneasy here. As you wake you notice that two of you are missing. You quickly discover what happened:  Andrew and musicalcakes lay dead in their own bedrolls both with slit throat. You search them carefully but find nothing that would point to their role in the gold theft. Seems like another day of discussion is before you."
 
 
 Andrew425 , Townie was killed.
 musicalcakes, Townie was killed.
 
 It is now Day.
 Day end next Wednesday 8 PM GMT.

[Urist Imiknorris]

Oh fuck, we have a SK.

That Other Urist, what do you think about this?

Orangebottle. what opinions have you formed?

[Orangebottle]

Andrew: I don't like how you were trying to save diakron back there. It's like you were subtly trying to either call musicalcakes scum or protect your scumbuddy.

There was nothing subtle about it.

What, I'm not allowed to use hyperbole? What is the world coming to these days? Then again, it was subtle enough for Andrew to miss it.

Oh fuck, we have a SK.

That Other Urist, what do you think about this?

Orangebottle. what opinions have you formed?

I think Shark is scum because of his attempted rolefishing,

Personally, I think Andrew must have an interesting role or something. I can't think of any reasons for a vanilla town/scum to act like he is right now. Anyone else have any thoughts on this?

Also, survivor was listed as a possible role. Maybe he finds this scenario risk/reward because, what I can tell is that the reward for him is making people look at other people, not him.

Also all this is taking the spotlight off of diak who is conveniently not posting. Hmm...

there.

Unvote
Diakron

Jumping back on the diakron train. I put my vote an andrew to try and prod him into saying things, but diak's more suspicious overall, and stopped posting.

And voting diakron for the sake of voting diakron, even though diakron had more than enough votes at that point and Shark could've used his vote as pressure for scumhunting.

My predecessor needs to learn more, lest he become another bdthemag.

Whoever killed Andrew made a pro-town move. Now the town's going to be less confused, so we'll be able to hunt better. This is why I think it's more likely that we have a Vig instead of an SK.
Now, I'd like to ask you something, Urist Imiknorris. Why did you immediately rule out the possibility of a vigilante and jump straight to SK?

[Urist Imiknorris]

The list of possible roles in the OP.

[Urist Imiknorris]

EBWOP: Maybe I should have looked at it again before assuming the second kill was an SK.

[musicalcakes]

Well, that was fun while it lasted.

Lurk mode, engage!

[Jim Groovester]

Oh fuck, we have a SK.

What a nice SK to kill the person everybody suspected.

No, it's probably a vig.

I think Shark is scum because of his attempted rolefishing, there.

Idle speculation about roles really isn't rolefishing, especially for somebody who's new like Shark who probably doesn't know any better. (Although it gets close to rolefishing.)

But I guess that won't stop you from repeating what McArathos said about it, for whatever reason. To look active and fluff up your attack probably.

And voting diakron for the sake of voting diakron, even though diakron had more than enough votes at that point and Shark could've used his vote as pressure for scumhunting.

No, when the day rolls to night, every players' vote should be on the person they suspect, not floating around as pressure votes. Provided Shark actually suspected Diakron, then he hasn't done anything wrong by voting him at the end of the day.

Meanwhile, I recall that his vote was floating around for pressure (on Andrew425) for a good portion of Day 1, so you're accusing him for not doing something he did.

So what are you giving him crap for again? It looks like absolutely nothing to me.

Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, Orangebottle.

[Urist Imiknorris]

Oh fuck, we have a SK.

What a nice SK to kill the person everybody suspected.

You assume the vig(?) killed Andrew. Why?