This is not an argument. This is a list of Mindmaker's posts. Summarizing them tells me nothing.
You need to have a point that you're making, and you need to find the best evidence that supports that point. Not all evidence possible.
Fine, fair enough.
1) He's doing a hell of a lot of "active lurking". His posts are, by and large, responses to other people, but he's doing practically no scumhunting. That makes me think that he's scum or AT BEST he's doing nothing to help town.
2) Post [8] is, like, the lamest cop out for not scumhunting ever. Look at the questions being asked by everyone else and get inspiration from that. Or, at least, analyze what other people are posting and focus on that.
3) His responses to questions tend toward defensiveness [12], [13], [20] at least.
4) Took over FOUR days between asking any substantial question to anyone
5) Voting for mipe9 after two other people had voted for him. In other scumhunting guides I've seen (mafiascum.net) that's in the common range for scum to throw in their hat on a bandwagon. Also suspicious since this was the first real activity against anyone he'd made in four days.
6) Possibly not a strong tell, but his wording in post [16] ("you" instead of "we")
7) Confronted by Mormota about his lack of activity, he reponds with an attack against Mormota instead of ... well, anything of value.
He's done
nothing to help the town side. He's been responding defensively, and has poor justification for his actions. He's scum, and I would like to see him hang.