Sorry about the delay, but I was NOT going to try and post from my phone again after that bullshit. Anyway, as promised, my response.
Dariush - He makes a lot of sense sometimes. Hasn't participated a lot though. I'm leaning town.
I'm not, but more on that in a bit.
Urist_McArathos - Lots of funny vibes. I get the feeling he's trying very hard not to attract attention, by overly explaining things, not trying to tread on anyone or their opinions, being extremely careful with how he votes, and so on. In other words, he's very much more concerned with looking like town than actually hunting scum, and he has a good idea of how to do it.
...
This list was constructed by rereading through Day 1 since that's the only thing I have to look at right now. Urist_McArathos by this list.
Okay, so let me see if I get this. Yesterday, after a thorough battery of questioning, you tell me
"you don't have anything on (me) anyway", yet decide FIRST THING this morning that, hey, actually, you do after all? There's nothing different from your case you already dismissed yourself, yet now it's worth pressing? I find that change of
mind somewhat suspect,
Jim. However, I've got nothing to hide, so let's have my rebuttal.
1. Overly explaining things: I'm wordy, no denials there. I fail to see how trying my hardest to be clear, thorough, and transparent in my reasoning is scummy. I'm letting you guys get a nice, fat read on me with every juicy, detailed post. It would be WIFOM to openly state that I cannot be scum because of this, but I
would like to know why it's a scumtell instead of a town tell or just, hell, my meta? You personally have told me in several games to tone down the length of my replies, so it's nothing new.
2. Not treading on anyone's opinion. Sure, I guess. Oh, except for the fact I've been arguing with you, Dariush, and NUKE all throughout Day 1, and even pressed NUKE for a bit after the wagon was shifting away from him. Toaster didn't interest me, and I didn't see a point in getting involved in Max and Native's pissing contest. I'm hardly along there, so I think it's a tad untrue to say I'm gingerly avoiding conflict.
3. Being extremely careful with my vote. This one is straight up bullshit, Jim. You know that careless voting, and not really giving a damn who gets lynched is a MAJOR scumtell. Town should ALWAYS be careful with their votes, because Town have something to lose with a mislynch. You can't deny if I was being reckless and flippant with my vote you'd call it scummy, so why is the exact opposite a scumtell? You're putting me in a lose-lose situation with this so-called scumtell Jim. Why would you do that, when you know better?
In any case, Urist is scum for the same reasons as yesterday.
Which are what, again?
Allow me to answer that. He's accused me of being
"Too Town" (and now he's trying to weasel out of that by saying "Oh, I didn't mean that in the way that makes me look scummy, sorry it took me nearly a fucking week to clarify that, I certainly wasn't scrambling for a way to avoid looking scummy in my response"). In that same post he accused me of voting NUKE for no reason (my response
here proves that's just flat-out not true). He also accused me of jumping on the NUKE bandwagon despite having LESS of a case against NUKE than me, and has accused me of avoiding the arguments in the game and lurking by sitting back and watching. First off, not true (I've been arguing with three different people AND answering Jack and Toaster's questions all damn Day 1), and second it's mighty hypocritical coming from someone who's been prodded by the GM and had several players ask him where the fuck he's been all game long. Someone's lurking here, but it's not me. It's almost like he's determined to lynch me, no matter how terrible his case is or how I respond to his baseless and patently false accusations.
Is it any wonder I'm still voting
Dariush as I was at the end of Day 1?
Hey, yeah.
D2.
Anyway. Blocked toaster, did not get converted. QED, toaster is the cult leader.
Told you so.
If you are being 100% honest in everything you say here, this tells us two and ONLY two things.
1. Toaster was blocked.
2. You are still town.
Could you explain to me how this proves that someone else wasn't the cult leader, and didn't just convert someone else? While eliminating the jailer before he can fuck up any night actions seems like a sound strategy, it's been established you cannot assume that scum will play competently just because they are scum. I'd really like to hear a stronger case against Toaster from you than this.
Author
Topic: Cult Mafia - GAME OVER - Psomeone Pscrewed Up (Read 85171 times)