I suppose that it will always be the draw-back of a game like the Elder Scrolls. When sword-fighting, magic and stealth all have to squeeze together in one game, there is only so much space that each of them can have. It cannot be a fantastic sneaky-thiefy-stabby-swipy-game, for it must also be a satisfying fency-hacky-slashy-bashy experience, as well as a abracadabra-zappy-freezy-burny-magic experience.
(By the by, I rather like my hyphonic system of classification, but I fear it might be too unwieldy for everyday use)
I can settle for second best, or merely good. As long as it is engaging and stimulating, it will do. Nonetheless, a rumour-based system of reputation cannot be beyond the wit of men to put in. After all, in Skyrim, they managed to make people send goons after you for stealing their things. And, of course, make the guards a little less helpless in their pursuit of justice. Enough careless theft in one place, and your disreputable-o-meter reaches a point where you get a bounty and an appointment with the gaol; that is just one idea. Of course, saving the city from the invading killer teapots, descending from Earl Grey's flying tea-tray fortress, should be enough to outweigh being prosecuted for stealing some of Mrs. Spacefiller's spoons.
As an aside, I... Well. It is peculiar, but with the state of their modding policy, and their less than re-assuring attitude, and with all the time passed, I am much less keen on any future Elder Scrolls release than I was. In fact, sometimes I feel that it would be better if they did not release another one, for under current mangement, it would not be a very good addition to the series at all.
It is an impression that saddens me. That is not how the world ought to be, particularly for me, who loves Tamriel so deeply, for whom it is so significant and meaningful. It should be an exciting thought; the possibility of the next Elder Scrolls, and not a worry. Not the fear of a disappointment and embarrassment to the series looming in the future. I must sit down sometime and work through these feelings, but I cannot say that I am hopeful for its future. But then again, one must always be willing to be surprised. Perhaps, perhaps.