Entire post has been edited.
1. As I've stated numerous times already: Terenos has received blatant favoritism. You basically attempted to railroad the Ligorians. Metagaming has not been dealt with as it should.
2. If you needed an antagonist that badly, it could have been run by a GM. As I've already stated, there is major precedent in the YaK universe for NPC Antagonists, there is zero excuse for what happened with Terenos. You could have maybe not provided such blatant favorism so as to put them onto rails to begin with? Just maybe!
3. In the future, do the above. The war-weary Ligorians should return to Ligoria to find that rebels, funded by an outside source, have essentially taken over the fortress. The DE should mistake Tala for a traitor and send assassins to hunt her and her lover down, if she does not return to Ligoria and share in their misfortune -- naturally she can prove them wrong later, but for now this should be the case. You should acknowledge your mistakes. No excuses, no reasons. Just state that you realize where you went wrong here.
Had I been present for the beginning of the Arctic Fox thing, I would have protested it in favor of having Terenos act as a GM, ruling only on things related to the AF Events. This was not the case, we cannot go back in time. There it is.
So basically I'm asking for:
- Acknowledgement of mistakes.
- Punishment for the metagamers.
- A promise not to make said mistakes again.
I'd also like to see Terenos never be a GM, but I'll pick my battles. Do what you want in that regard, as long as he never rolls anything for me.