...
So should I re-open the voting thread for this matter?
I think that Pm'ing for secret rolls is interesting, it's surprising and it keeps you on your toes, you don't know whats going to happen next, you don't know what the people have planned and can't think "Wow I think becuase those guys on the other side of the feild are outnumbered, that they have something planned, im going to call off the charge!" .
Plus it makes it so that you can't just say, "I just randomly chop the culprit's head off, becuase i'm chaotic and i don't like him, oh and would you look at that? He has the knife that stabbed the general! What luck!"
Theres a hundred tiny ways you can meta-game, that ae barely noticable but can be used to give yourself a bonus. You could look for clues that aren't there and find one that proves that someone did it.
Say if someone murdered somebody, then the queen decides that that person looks a bit suspicous and asks for a tail to be put on him. Then they discover that he murdered somebody.
Life's not fair. Getting murdered by a spy is part of being a noble, you can't expect everything, and if we continued playing in the old one, Kain would most likely be dead. I would find it an annoying surprise, then gen a new char, while posting some crap about Amaryills being pregnent with Kain's son.
But in my opinoin, if something bad happens and it don't fit in your plans and you don't know who did it:
GET OVER IT AND HUNT THEM DOWN.