I wasn't tarring them
all with the same brush, but I've seen too many "utilities" that don't quite do what they say they do, or even end up working badly because they're hardware-unaware in some way (gone are the days when a good defrag makes a slow machine faster - or at least shows you definitively that you've got way too little unused space to defrag via - and it's positively recomended
against with SSD tech and even now with on-drive management systems controlling platter use behind a kind of Firmware HAL, hiding and 'dealing with' corrupt sectors from most non-manufacturer tools unless they're fully SMART compliant/whatever).
So that's where my cynicism is based. Probably not as bad as I think it is. But, by dint of my working with hardware that needs fixing (even if I tend to put off fixing my
own), I see/notice a lot more problems.
("Fast, Cheap, Good: choose
one, if you're lucky" seems to often apply, in my world.
)
As for Seasonal Saves, I just like them. For historical reasons, in both senses. I don't usually use them (have to, or go into them for save-scumming purposes) very often at all, but I like the safety net. I'm most likely to go into (a copy of) one to re-run some experiment to see what might have happened if I'd dug a ditch/magmaduct/cavern-entrance in another way, or set up my workshops in a different manner/priority. Then revert to the "true" save to continue where I left off. And seasonal saves at least does the job of pre-anticipating my need for a test copy of the gamestate. Also, so long as I don't tidy them up often (move them around* or delete them from the disc entirely) then they're sat on prime disc-space
preventing it from suffering from further RW-stress for the duration.
It does also reflect the fact that I'm a data-hoarder by nature. Loads of old-versions of files that I'm probably not even needing ever to access the
newest version of the file (or can remember where it is, if I can even remember I might have it at all). Add that to my personal quirk-list, if you will.
* Okay, so moving files, and even directories, on the same disc probably has minimal RW load. Just the FAT record(s).