You take a look outside. Sand and tall, spiky rocks. Really tall. Like twenty feet. And it's also completely dark - you can't even see the moons for some reason. The stars are still out, though, and they're almost bright enough to see by. Weird.
Yeah, WEIRD. Though, I guess that might just mean the moons are behind the cave or something, so they aren't at a good angle for us to see. I'm really hoping that's the explanation... a lot.
You head back inside and try to wake Laureli up. She mumbles something, but you can't quite make it out. Something that sounded like 'r'? Or 'w'? Or 'l', maybe? You can't tell.
Give her a red pill, then a white pill.
Then the liquid.
NONONONO! For all we know she could have said "Run!"
I mean, for all we know, the silvery liquid is arctic unicorn piss.
And this! Didn't we have a vial of some murky silvery liquid, and it was not something you'd rather digest?
So many possible consequences!
Okay, so, sit down... think... calm...
She wouldn't carry the pills as an offensive weapon, since they'd need to be taken pretty much willingly. Chances are they are something she brought to take.
The liquid, though, could be used similar to how we use our powers... although it seems far more likely she's a wind user.
So
Give her a red... see if anything happens. Give her a white... See if anything happens.
and pray.