Sorry for the delay.
Christopher Daubernon here.
Simple: I assume there could be non-magical killers or non-killing magical entities.
Dariush:
Dariush: Fine: not changing it, but adding little details after the fact to excuse what others are claiming against you.
Ahem. How was I supposed to know that my facial hair will concern someone in the future?
It's more than just that- your claim has been generally poor.
I stated a theory which may or may not be true (but probably is). Again, I had no way of knowing that the fact I'm using a spell to track a bracelet would be relevant in the future. Do you take me for an Oracle?
Do you have any basis for this theory? Who do you think is the wizard?
Also, how are you casting this spell?
Also, a thought just struck me - Think isn't necessarily a medium, but may be another witch who can sense magic, and his Jim's quote is either fully made up or comes from the scumchat. Really, what could have prevented Jim from LYING? If it is true, it would be insanely easy for Think to frame me using details I haven't yet revealed. Or there might be no wizard at all, but just the last witch (Think) with an NK that we attributed to wizard. Really, the whole current situtation hangs on the fact that we assume him to be telling the truth, since most of the information about witches comes from his quote. Unvote meanwhile.
Doesn't this require Think to know these details about you before you reveal them? This is extremely convoluted.
Anyway, I think I've cracked this case. Let's run down the list:
Toaster: Inquisitor. Town.
Flandre: Lover with Jim. Town. Will die tonight (If not, lynch him.)
Dariush: Wizard. Self-aligned. Lynch him today. [1]
Think: Medium. Witch-aligned/ally. I guess he'll lose by default if he can't win?
Irony: The third witch. Lynch him D5.
Simple: The other killer. Lynch him D4.
It's
possible I have Simple and Irony backwards, but I don't think so.
[1] I do have an alternate theory if he's telling the truth. If he is lynched and isn't a wizard, it's Think, who just happens to be a medium as well, and they're knowingly aligned, with Dariush scouting and Think killing. This is unlikely due to the Vector issue, but I wanted to put it out there. Simple, if Dariush isn't the wizard, you should kill Think. Think, you should kill Simple for being about to kill you.
Reasoning for all this below:
First up is Dariush:
In reply 167, he mentions
giant footprints outside his window- a window he probably doesn't have in a barn. Looks to me like he's putting out something to cover something he already knows.
In retrospect,
this is a pretty blatant bandwagon, indicative of someone who doesn't really care about who he lynches.
Next is Irony.
Why do I think he's the last witch? Couple reasons.
Here he is lightly defending Urist from Max, and returning fire in the process. Noteworthy is that
Irony's RV questions are to both known witches. I'll grant it's a very weak reason, but I want it out there anyway.
That would of course leave out Simple as the other killer. I don't think Urist would
have been so on top of him if they were allied, though this is far from sure.
I couldn't get much on Think, so I default to believing his claim, unless the Dariush team idea I mentioned above holds. Dariush's lynch should bear that out, though.
One question, though- how is Jim a maiden if he's been sodomizing/being sodomized by* Flandre?
*I can't hold back asking any more- which is it?