I honestly cannot fathom at this point what more you are looking for, other than you trying to weasel out of a lynch... which it appears you've pulled off.
-Why asking about Ottofar, after stating nonconclusive opinions on him, heavily implies that I'm scum
-Why you didn't state why you thought that way when you were pushing your case
-Why getting you to state your core reasons for thinking me scum was like pulling teeth
-Why you continue to feel you shouldn't have had to explain your reasons, beyond the simplest of terms
And others, but those are the ones that immediately come to mind. Of course, these are all assuming answers more complicated than "because you're scum," "I didn't realize I needed to spell it out for you," "deal with it," and so on, which you have given.
I have explained this one. Right here, second paragraph in your section.
Really. This?
Let me be more specific, then: There's not much to be had in guessing the motivations of scum (Example: Nightkill target selection). Getting the motivations of people so you can decide if they are scum is very valuable.
This is going to become an argument of mincing words, isn't it?
All this does is turn "I'm not one for guessing your motivations, so here's my guess at your motivations" into
"Why didn't you do that? I'm not much for guessing the motivations of your team, but if I had to say here's your motivations." It does absolutely nothing to explain why you'd bring it up at all.
That's bullshit and you know it. It's fine to not have a concrete opinion of someone. Explicitly not having one then (in the same breath, even) asking people about their opinions of said person is.
I disagree that asking people their opinions to get them is scummy when there's a good reason to do so. Is asking about a massclaim scummy also?
Now you're just taking my statements completely out of context and bringing in irrelevant crap. (And of course it isn't.)
Then provide said context to show how scummy I am. Trying to push it aside with vague accusations is worthless, and you should really know this from being in this position to begin with.
Since another extension would probably run toward being counterproductive, I'm not going to bother. However, let me drop my final scumlist:
Irony is obvscum
Solifuge is probably scum, because he's humping Toaster's #1 Scumtell like a madman
Ottofar is probably a survivor
Vector reads misguided townie
I still say the D1 Darvi wagon was crap, so I don't suspect him
Good luck town!
I'm not sure I agree, since we appear to be missing half the game.
Also, no read on Think? He's been here, somewhat.