Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Powder Miner]

What if both you and Irony are scum?

[Jim Groovester]

IronyOwl and I HAVE to be on the same team.

Yep, that's what I'm worried about.

Instead of lynching somebody who could potentially be a sane/insane cop, how about we no lynch instead, play this out cautiously, and instead get even more results to confirm who's what type of cop.

You wanting to rush through a lynch already is suspect. There's no need for it, unless you're worried the scum baseline you've set up by choosing yourself and IronyOwl as the first two inspects will be shattered upon further inspections, which there'll be a lot of unless you start lynching now.

It's actually pointless to focus all the inspects on me, because it's already certain that webadict and IronyOwl are already different alignments from me. It would be more fruitful to inspect somebody else, somebody who's gotten a different result between webadict and their first target like I did. I pick Darvi. It'll have the same effect to show who the insane/sane cops are, but it's vastly more informative since we'll have inspects on more people.

It'll also show that there are more people who have alignments different from IronyOwl and webadict, which will then prove that they're scum and we can lynch them.

[Heliman]

So, I'm willing to risk that.

Sheb.

That means Dariush and Irony should investigate Heliman while Bdthemag, Darvi, TolyK, and I investigate Powder Miner. Sheb is lynched today, proving your innocence and my innocence, Jim Groovester is lynched tomorrow, and the following day is lynching whichever one of Powder Miner or Heliman is left.

Game broken and it's only Day 2. Good run.

Now, anyone see any holes in this plan?

One hole, or rather, one opportunity cost: If we no-lynch tonight, everyone who inspected Jim Groovester can inspect Sheb instead. Then we Lynch Jim, and if he flips town, we lynch you. A no-lynch is also a free day because of end game parity (if we lynch 1 scum and cant find the other, lynching one person per day, we will have a 1:1 parity instead of a 1:0 at the end.)
I, for one, actually vote for a No Lynch too.

It's actually pointless to focus all the inspects on me, because it's already certain that webadict and IronyOwl are already different alignments from me. It would be more fruitful to inspect somebody else, somebody who's gotten a different result between webadict and their first target like I did. I pick Darvi. It'll have the same effect to show who the insane/sane cops are, but it's vastly more informative since we'll have inspects on more people.

Bullshit, much of the town can determine their alignments FOR SURE by inspecting you tonight and lynching you tomorrow. If you flip town tomorrow, then we'll know exactly who the two scum are and who to lynch.

It'll also show that there are more people who have alignments different from IronyOwl and webadict, which will then prove that they're scum and we can lynch them.

A better way to prove that would be just lynching you.

[Toaster]

Vote Count:

IronyOwl:
Bdthemag:
Jim Groovester:
Dariush:
Darvi:
TolyK:
Sheb: Dariush, webadict
webadict:
Powder Miner:
Heliman:

No Lynch: Jim Groovester, Heliman

Not voting: IronyOwl, TolyK, Powder Miner, Sheb, Darvi, Bdthemag


Day 2 will last until Wednesday, 6/18 at 11 PM EST.

[IronyOwl]

No Lynch and Shorten.

Let's get the inspects and move on.

[Jim Groovester]

Oppose shorten.

Aren't you forgetting something?

[IronyOwl]

Right. Web was right the first time, I got Town on him.

[Jim Groovester]

Then how come you voted and shortened before you mentioned your all important inspect result?

It's almost like you forgot you were supposed to be a cop.

[webadict]

Right. Web was right the first time, I got Town on him.

That's not what I said at all.

[Jim Groovester]

WUBA, how come you went ahead and did all your analysis before you got IronyOwl's result?

That's fishy.

[Powder Miner]

Like I said... What if both webadict and IronyOwl are mafia?
What if, webadit? Answer me this time.

[IronyOwl]

Right. Web was right the first time, I got Town on him.

That's not what I said at all.

My bad. Nonetheless, I got town on you.

[Jim Groovester]

Answer me, scum.

[IronyOwl]

Because I thought web had already mentioned it, and he'd certainly gone through all the hypothetical discussions of what it meant. I figured we were done for today.

[Jim Groovester]

How the fuck would WUBA know that you got a town result on him if you're not on the same team?