Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[lordnincompoop]

Define 'scum'.

Mafia - You win if there are no other killers alive and your team equals or outnumbers the number of remaining players. You mafiakill a player each Night.

[Max White]

Max White, how much have you gathered about the players so far? What scumtells would be the most obvious to you?

Are you looking for logical reasoning, or just hunches? Because at this point I don't think I can provide the first.

[Pandarsenic]

Define 'scum'.

Mafia - You win if there are no other killers alive and your team equals or outnumbers the number of remaining players. You mafiakill a player each Night.

For several players, the mafia is hardly the biggest problem. Are you, perhaps, a bit too worried about being shot? Are you, perhaps, a cult leader?

[Think0028]

LNCP: Yes this setup will be difficult, as unless I'm culted, I won't really be able to rely on anyone else for help. Even as town, normally, there's the comfort of knowing that out there, there are innocent people with the same goal as you. Here, while we have similar short term goals (kill the Cultist, (probably) kill the SK), I have to try to progress those while actually working at a cross purpose to everyone else. As for questions, who would you lynch given a choice so far?

Powder Miner: What role are you, personally, worried about the most? Do you have any suspects for roles at the moment?

[Toaster]

Jim:

Jim:  Who is most important to lynch D1?

Depends on your alignment. For most everybody, that'd be Cult, because a runaway cult will screw over the most win conditions. After that, it's mafia and SK, with the next most harmful win conditions to everybody else.

What's your opinion? Who should we all, with all our disparate win conditions, gun for, if anybody?

I was thinking the SK, but you make a good argument for Cult.


Max:

Hey everybody, it's ok, Think0028 is the jester! That is at least one vital roll identified. Anybody here the martyr?

What is this nonsense accomplishing?


Darvi:

Darvi:  What non-game-ending lynch would be worst D1?

Worst for whom exactly?

1.  Most people?
2.  You?


Think:

LNCP: Yes this setup will be difficult, as unless I'm culted, I won't really be able to rely on anyone else for help. Even as town, normally, there's the comfort of knowing that out there, there are innocent people with the same goal as you. Here, while we have similar short term goals (kill the Cultist, (probably) kill the SK), I have to try to progress those while actually working at a cross purpose to everyone else. As for questions, who would you lynch given a choice so far?

Why "probably" the SK?



LNCP:  It's a more cerebral game, since it's basically a Xanatos clusterfuck.  Everyone is trying to manipulate everyone else to determine who is for or against their objective.  For the second part of your question, see points to Think and Max.



Powder:  Would you rather lynch the SK or Mafia?


BD:  Let's say you're the Mafioso.  Which role would you most like dead?


Pandar:  Let's say you're the Cult Leader.  Which role would you most like to convert?


Dariush:  Let's say you're the Survivor.  Which role do you think would be best to help?

[Think0028]

"Probably" because there's also the Ally, so there's two people who initially want the SK alive, versus 1 for the Cult. Also was wondering about SK killing possibly clearing out a problem role on N1 at least, like Jester or Cult.

[Max White]

What is this nonsense accomplishing?

He didn't seem to care that I was drawing attention to him.

[Toaster]

Why did you feel the need to draw attention to him?

[Max White]

To see what he did. He did nothing, so I am satisfied.

[Toaster]

What would have been a bad reaction?

[Max White]

Responding as if it were some great big attack would have made me think he is paranoid about being attacked, and so most likely has a reason for people to attack him.

[Jim Groovester]

Jim Groovester, if you were scum, what faction would you want to eliminate first? The last?

SK, then Cult. SK, because he might kill me, Cult because having a giant unanimous voting block at the end of the game would suck. It might be smart to shoot for the Cult first, so that they can't get the ball rolling. Even by Day 3, a three member cult can be pretty damaging.

Martyr, for obvious reasons.

[Max White]

Jim Groovester: When you question people, do you use a randomiser, or do you hand pick people?

[Powder Miner]

Hmm. I'm most worried about the Cult, as they can start getting majorities fairly quickly, espcially when you think about mafia and sk... Left unhecked, a cult could effectively win in two or three days.
I think I'd lynch Mafia, because then the MAfia-lly (if he provides a threat like I think he does) would also be taken out of the equation, as would the brother.
As a scumpartner, I'd choose Toaster, as he's a very experienced player, and not as much of a kill magnet as Jim. least, to tell the truth, supercharazad, as- I hate to insult him- but he didn't leave a very good impression on me from last game.

[Toaster]

Powder:

As a scumpartner, I'd choose Toaster, as he's a very experienced player, and not as much of a kill magnet as Jim.

I've picked up a bunch of N1 NKs lately, actually.

One for you:  If the cult was still around on D3, would you try to get recruited?

Same question to LNCP.