Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[IronyOwl]

Plate of Bacon is almost assuredly SD, with a slight chance of someone who joined after him. Leaning towards Darvi's suspicion on Pandar, but it could also be... something else.

Anyway...


Pandar, what do you expect in terms of factions and scum numbers?

Native, preferred scumbuddies? Those you'd least want as scum as town?

Org, how do you feel about having several noobs/unknowns in a game this... complex?

wait. there are 13 of us and 15 roles, right? 
wtf?

I count 15.

[Darvi]

I'm suspecting Pandar? Were? :y

[TolyK]

o right.

Native, who would your scumbuddy be? How would you play this game today?

[IronyOwl]

Er, your suspicion of his role.

[Darvi]

Ah. Then it turns out to be somebody entirely else.

BECAUSE YOU DON't EXPECT IT!

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

NativeForeigner, the chances of me picking dragon are
indeed good but your assumption that it would mean I
was scum because of it is off. The roles I believe are
divided up randomly between the teams. So that could
mean that the dragons are on the same team and
connected or they could be on opposing teams.  As for
the roles its all pretty mix up, mash up. Some of them
because of who joined where pretty clear form the start
in some form or another but nothing is written in stone and
picking a role someone else would pick would be a good
way to hide yourself, such as say choosing dragon when
I am playing.

[TolyK]

i feel that with that post akhier is either cult or scum.

[Darvi]

What makes you think that?

[NativeForeigner]

Native, preferred scumbuddies? Those you'd least want as scum as town?

I would prefer either Pandar or Jokerman as a scumbuddy. They're both respectably experienced players and we'd be able to communicate and plan easily. Least want as scum: You because you're difficult to read (for me), BD because I always get some sort of false read off of him, and SaintDraze for the same reason as BD. As town: BD (see previous), SaintDraze (see previous), and anyone else that's likely to get themselves mislynched.

TolyK: Whomever Wuba assigns as my scumbuddy. If you're asking who I would prefer, see the above. As for how I'll play, just like the other BYOR games.

Also, that's a rather large jump, but yeah, I feel it too. It's way too defensive.

Akhier: Why so defensive?

[Jack A T]

I have this strange feeling that SaintDraze is the bacon.  For some reason.

IronyOwl: What do you think of the two dragons?

TolyK: How do you think the public role list will effect the game?

Org: What do you think of the switched day/night activity?

SniHjen: Who do you think would be most dangerous as mafia?  As cult?  As SK?

[TolyK]

leaving liike right now.

NativeForeigner, the chances of me picking dragon are
indeed good but your assumption that it would mean I
was scum because of it is off. You would say. or you could be in a cult. The roles I believe are
divided up randomly between the teams. So that could
mean that the dragons are on the same team and
connected or they could be on opposing teams. counterintuitive As for
the roles its all pretty mix up, mash up. ... how do you know that they aren't grouped, mr scum? Some of them
because of who joined where pretty clear form the start
in some form or another but nothing is written in stone and
picking a role someone else would pick would be a good
way to hide yourself, such as say choosing dragon when
I am playing. ... but there are two of them.

dissected that post.

@native the ninja: gotcha.

@Jack AT the ninja: it will probably lead to folks guessing who is on what side. also folks will be guessing abilities. it also lists targets for sk's and scum.

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

   Native and TolyK, I don't like logical fallacy that is
so obvious. If the roles are going to random teams then
being a dragon does not mean your teamed with a
dragon, nor does it mean you are scum. Lets clear this
up right now.

Webadict, is alignment random?

[NativeForeigner]

   Native and TolyK, I don't like logical fallacy that is
so obvious. If the roles are going to random teams then
being a dragon does not mean your teamed with a
dragon, nor does it mean you are scum. Lets clear this
up right now.

You're being really defensive about it, though. If it was really as much a fallacy as you would have us believe, you'd simply dismiss it. "No, I'm not on a scumteam with the other dragon", but you didn't. You put way too much effort way too soon to trying to convince us that there's no connection. That only confirms that there is one. You might not be scum (but I think you are), but you're definitely with the other dragon.

[IronyOwl]

Native: Interesting. Who can you read accurately, semi-accurately, and so on?

IronyOwl: What do you think of the two dragons?

For me, the big question is whether they're the same type of dragon. It's possible two players sent in similar enough links/descriptions that web decided to make them identical, but it's also possible that they're completely separate roles that happen to have the same name.

If they are identical or very close, I'd indeed expect them to be related in some way- mason group, opposed powers, or something along those lines. Since I'm leaning more towards them being separate, I'm more inclined to assume there's no relation.

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

   Native, you assumed I was dragon...

Okay I can't argue that one. Then you assumed I was
scum just because I was a dragon. That presses a button
for me because I LOVE dragons and do not believe that
a dragon would have to be auto-evil. You assumed a
connection which to be fair is a possible link but that is
not any kind of certainty. I am not putting too much into
it I am just writing some and with my tricky formatting it
looks like a lot more.

or non-formatted:

Native, you assumed I was dragon. Okay I can't argue that one. Then you assumed I was scum just because I was a dragon. That presses a button for me because I LOVE dragons and do not believe that a dragon would have to be auto-evil. You assumed a connection which to be fair is a possible link but that is not any kind of certainty. I am not putting too much into it I am just writing some and with my tricky formatting it looks like a lot more.