Why do we need a new plan? I personally cannot see how it would fail. The only way it would fail would be if Native and Pandar's alibi aren't airtight, and I've overlooked something that might have them be scum, otherwise, the three of us are the only suspects, and we can all die with relative safety.
Native's is, but Pandar's requires he be telling the truth, unless there's some reason he couldn't be an ascetic or something.
I CAN agree to target you, Irony, though I'm not sure if my own kill duplicated against me would also have a 50% chance of failure. I just think it's a risk. Either way, I'd like Pandar to target you as well
Not sure about the first part. Second part would be sound if the plan was, but at this point it's looking less like "we make it physically impossible for scum to win" and more like "we kill each other a lot and then hope that works out."
Part of the problem, as I see it, is that at least one of our kills has a fail rate. If we lynch LNCP, then me, Pandar, and Josh could form a death triangle, but at least one link would only have a 50% chance of working. I nominate myself, for two reasons.
First of all, it might be better for me to karma Pandar because we'd know for a fact that it'd work (unless he's somehow immune to inspects and kills). Secondly, it precludes any shenanigans if LNCP's lying about his revive being lynch-only, since he'd be guaranteed dead once.
That'd leave a 50% chance of Native, either a confirmed townie or unfathomably lucky, as the sole survivor, and a 50% chance of him being alone with me. Unless I'm both scum and have some vote/revive nonsense, that'd leave it at a stalemate.