Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jokerman-EXE]

I got Town on Toaster as well.

[JoshuaFH]

I have everything I want now. I don’t see the point in another extension.

Before we hammer, I’ll allow Native and Otto to answer Toaster’s questions.

I would like to suggest something though:

King Mafia, a rational move right now would be to give up, and reveal yourself. It’s not possible to hide from this many investigatory roles, and the very best you could hope for is to take out one in the struggle. A rational choice would be to allow yourself to be lynched, so all of these investigatory roles can make it to the next round, so that we can trounce King Mafia there as well, and you will have another chance to become King Mafia in the future, a possibility rendered more likely if you leave powerful town roles, like myself and Toaster, alive.

[Ottofar]

Unless the King Mafia was a godfather or somesuch.

[Toaster]

Native:  You're now L-1.  Who do you think is scum?  Why?  What's your opinion on how best to proceed with the known roles to maximize our knowledge?


Ottofar:  Same questions to you.

[Ottofar]

Busy, after-migraining. Can't really think straight.

Anyways, JMan, for that contradiction stuff,
or maybe Josh for again running a plan, which will certainly catch the King Mafia, just like round 5.

 So yeah.

[Ottofar]

Joshua, do you still have the role Org had?

Isn't Forensics expert oneshot?

[JoshuaFH]

It doesn't say oneshot, so I assume that it can be fired as many times as I get the opportunity to.

[NativeForeigner]

I'm getting a bit of an off feeling towards Josh, he was really pushing to lynch me, even if it did make sense. However, I don't really trust Jokerman, it seems a little too convenient that he simply "forgot" about his inspect and kill role, that's not something you really forget. Despite showing up as town to an inspect, it's possible that he has an auto-ability that lets him show up as town to inspects.

I suggest the next time you get a chance, inspect Ottofar and Josh. If no one shows up as scum, Jokerman's most likely King.

[Azure Sepulchre]

It doesn't say oneshot, so I assume that it can be fired as many times as I get the opportunity to.

Don't assume with something as important as your role. I want a definite 'yes or no' answer before I'll commit to any plan involving it.   

[Pandarsenic]

Don't be obtuse. The only assumption he's making is that Wuba didn't make a mistake in his Role PM, since a 1-shot ability is explicitly stated to be 1-shot.

Forensics Expert (town; uncommon; 12+ players): You may perform an autopsy on a dead player, possibly giving you information about that player's killer. Actions: (day)autopsy

There.

It's not a one-shot.

Can we stop herping yet?

[Toaster]

I'm getting a bit of an off feeling towards Josh, he was really pushing to lynch me, even if it did make sense. However, I don't really trust Jokerman, it seems a little too convenient that he simply "forgot" about his inspect and kill role, that's not something you really forget. Despite showing up as town to an inspect, it's possible that he has an auto-ability that lets him show up as town to inspects.

I suggest the next time you get a chance, inspect Ottofar and Josh. If no one shows up as scum, Jokerman's most likely King.

Josh is scummy because he was pushing a lynch for a logical reason?  Seriously?

Everything else is attempts to sow suspicion.

[NativeForeigner]

I'm getting a bit of an off feeling towards Josh, he was really pushing to lynch me, even if it did make sense. However, I don't really trust Jokerman, it seems a little too convenient that he simply "forgot" about his inspect and kill role, that's not something you really forget. Despite showing up as town to an inspect, it's possible that he has an auto-ability that lets him show up as town to inspects.

I suggest the next time you get a chance, inspect Ottofar and Josh. If no one shows up as scum, Jokerman's most likely King.

Josh is scummy because he was pushing a lynch for a logical reason?  Seriously?

Everything else is attempts to sow suspicion.

He was pushing really hard for it, and the fact that it was logical makes it an easy, safe target for a mislynch.

Yes, sowing suspicion after my death would totally win me the game if I was King Mafia.

[Toaster]

It also makes it, you know, logical.

[JoshuaFH]

I’m sorry to say Native, but the last few posts of yours pretty much confirms that you’re King Mafia for me. Just the inability to form a coherent argument and general OMGUS’ing on me triggers in my mind that you’re either King Mafia, or a rather poor townie.

And I’m good with believing in the former. I believe that’s hammer.

In the off-chance that I'm wrong, everyone knows what to do.

[NativeForeigner]

Yeah, totally King Mafia. Oh wait, totally poor townie. Oh, wait again, being assaulted by something I can't really defend against. Yeah, that's it. Anyway, I still think King is Josh, another viable tactic would have been to just wait until everyone was inspected but me (because even if I was king and I killed, he would find out), but he ignored that possibility and went straight for the mislynch.