Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

   It still does not mean that one of us have to be scum.

[Darvi]

Then please explain how that would be possible, apart from a situation where scum doesn't lynch or where somebody didn't tell us about their protect action. Because, frankly, I don't see how that would work.

[IronyOwl]

I'm somewhat suspicious of Darvi's reasoning that Book absolutely could not have been the NK target, but it indeed seems less likely than usual. I'm not willing to wager the game on it, though, and there weren't exactly a lot of good targets.

Odds that the scumteam didn't attempt a kill seem extremely unlikely, especially with the threat of any player gaining an inspect item at any time.

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

*sigh* Do I have to reiterate everything?


There was no kill this night. Meaning one of 3 things:


a)The killer got blocked
b)the target got protected
c)kill never got attempted (which I just thought of actually)


Nobody got protected except for joker and Book, who I deem unlikely killtargets because of their comparatively suspicious behavior.
So that means the NKer got blocked, and since the only people who got blocked were you and Book, at least one of you must be scum.

Opinion != Fact

[Darvi]

Ya, point. But still, with people like Irony, Janus, and Tyberix around, why would they bother with one of the most suspicious people around?

[Org]

*sigh* Do I have to reiterate everything?


There was no kill this night. Meaning one of 3 things:


a)The killer got blocked
b)the target got protected
c)kill never got attempted (which I just thought of actually)


Nobody got protected except for joker and Book, who I deem unlikely killtargets because of their comparatively suspicious behavior.
So that means the NKer got blocked, and since the only people who got blocked were you and Book, at least one of you must be scum.


Unless of course scum didn't even attempt to NK, which I was asking Irony about.

   silly ninja, Book could have been the NK target.

Read. My. MOTHERFUCKING. POST DAMMIT!

Why would there be no kill, Dav?
Unless you know something about it or something,

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

   If everyone thought you would never choose a person why would you choose them?

[Darvi]

Well that's what I'm asking you.

Why would there be no kill, Dav?
Unless you know something about it or something,

Well that was what I was asking Irony. I don't think there was a no-kill either, I mean, why would anyone waste a perfectly good kill?

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

   So you think that they are so good they would never choose someone that is acting suspicious. Is it to much to think that they might know this and use it to their advantage?

[Darvi]

Er, wait. Damn, you're right.


Fuck, have to rethink again.

[Akhier the Dragon hearted]

   I will say though that my current scum theory has Book
being the one that was keeping Super inline and Supers
sudden change in the way he is acting is because the
puppet master is away.

[Darvi]

But there's 3 scum. Unless their partner wouldn't bother with something like that or simply isn't there often enough to check on him.


Anyway, I won't do the rethinking because the entire "would scum lynch a suspicious townie?" thing is pure WIFOM, and because it's 1 AM.


Going to bed now <_<

[Jokerman-EXE]

If we had two blocks going last night, then it's more probable that the kill was simply blocked. Which means that odds are that the kill was stopped and not avoided; trying to read into that situation is a bad idea.

[IronyOwl]

That only widens our suspects by one: Tyberix. Book was the only other one blocked, and he was a suspect anyway.

The only other explanation is that scum accidentally blocked their own (cantrips), then lied about it using an untestable claim.

[Toaster]

Vote Count:

Darvi: Tyberix
Org: IronyOwl
Tyberix:
Akhier the Dragon hearted: Darvi, Ottofar, Supercharazad
Ottofar:
JanusTwoface:
Supercharazad: Akhier the Dragon hearted, Jokerman-EXE, JanusTwoface
IronyOwl:
Jokerman-EXE:


Not Voting: Org,


Day 3 will last until 11 PM EST on Tuesday, 3/15, ~23 hours from now.


Reminder:  If you wish to do something other than quest for the day, please PM me and let me know.