All of these are directed at me, in some way or another. Why? "because he seems flaky" is not a reason.
Book: I am undecided, but I have a feeling he is scum. (As explained before, I have a feeling about him)
So,
Super, lack of reasons are good enough for you to suspect me, but not good enough for him to suspect you?
Tyberix: Town (due to my investigating, misfiring wand of goddamn cantrips)
Supercharazard: Town (because I saw my role PM)
This is a bit too convenient. But at least if you flip scum, we have good reason to be suspicious of him.
Super. Why haven't we killed him already?
Because I'm town. Jokerman: Why are you voting me without reason?
OMGUS, just sayin'
How is it an OMGUS? I FoS'd him ecause he acted scummy, by random voting.
Yeah Zrk how is that an OMGUS?
Calling someone out for voting for you without any reason other than 'you voted for me' seems an awful lot like an OMGUS to me.
No. He never voted him, only asking why he was even being voted.
((Heh, quote pyramids are fun.)) No,
Org, it
is an OMGUS even if it's just a FoS instead of a vote. The "scumtell" part of the OMGUS is the immediate reaction of attacking someone just because they attacked you without further reason (implying that they must be scum for questioning your towniehood alone), not whether it's painted red or blue. You
know this, so why are you defending Super?
My picks so far:Supercharazad: Seems scummier D2 than he did D1. His "townie" results on Tyberix seems suspect, plus his inconsistency about when are reasons needed, and his OMGUS on Jokerman, are added to his generally erratic behaviour.
Super: other than "because I'm town, and I know I'm town because I saw my PM", do you have any reasons for which we should believe you honestly suspect Jokerman, instead of it being an OMGUS, or for the trustworthiness of your "inspection" result? What are your reads on IronyOwl and Akhier?
Zrk2: Same reasons as D1; he has answered some, but I don't find him convincing.
Janus: you were concerned about a wagon on Zrk2 D1, and advocated a Saint lynch instead. Saint flipped town. How do you feel about this? Do you think you were misguided about interceding for Zrk2 yesterday? How about the wagon forming around him
today?Ottofar: lurky and laconical. Has seemed Orgier than Org lately, and was quick to jump on the
bandwagon.
Ottofar: Please give your reads on Janus, Jokerman & Darvi.
Org, although he seems more coherent than usual, I'm uncertain; at least he's not being silent-Org (which often means scum-Org), but his interceding for Super is suspicious.
IronyOwl and
Akhier dropped the useless fight from D1. While I'm glad of it (it was not that useful), I now wonder whether it was staged misdirection. I guess we'll see. At least Akhier was somewhat absolved from his buddy-seeming behaviour towards Saint, since he flipped town.
Both: Current scumpicks, read of the other, and you take on a final verdict over yesterday's disagreement would be welcome.