Painiac How would you choose doc target ,if you were one, on N1 ?
I would do scumhunt of course, and guess who is scum. It's always two people less to choose from. Next, I would try to guess which person is most agressive, experienced pro-town. Then next, wifom ensues. If scum is sly? Or want to kill most dangerous threat? Do he suspect that town has doc? Hell. I would probably not drink wine, and protect most pro-town guy anyway. Loss of less useful townie wouldn't hurt that much.
From the beginning he seems to response with vague answers that are simply factored with town look in mind,he avoids stating specific people just to have open way to bandwagon or defend them later. Also from the same beginning he seems to be sure that he will find two scum almost instantly. That's at least bad approach or scummy overconfidence.
Okay, un-FoS Japa. While there was some scummy things, your talk sounds good overall. Good luck on scumhunt, then.
Scumhunt is supossed to be aggresive. Look, he conviced me, and I'm not FoS-ing him now. I'm feeling some chainsawing here to protect him instead... Well, okay, if he is scum, I can always press him at another time.
First the strange need to say he noticed nothing wrong but at the same time there is "something" scummy just in case somebody asked about it. Why not tell us what's that then ? After that the very strange statement that scumhunt could be easened or postponed,while previous sentence says something opposite.
So, you threatening me now? If you will turn up townie, I will be persecuted? While you are maybe true, it is weird thing to said to townie. My survival is not my main target, I'm winning with team anyway. Yea, it would be bad to waste lynch over me, so I would bite and scumhunt with all my might. But survival isn't my main target. Yet, if you are scum, I can understand why survival is important to you.
Why even reconsider option that someone's town just because he says so ? On D1 this part could be only blind shooting or scum information. It wouldn't be as important if you not used it to retaliate on him. Concealed town-claim and hidden threat that you would attack anyone who would attack you ? Also i find it a bit strange that he never directly say someone's is scum concealing it behind "if you're scum ..." instead.
Painiac You would want to see hammer vote lynch in this game ? Why ?
I never stated I want hammer vote lynch. Yes, I am pretty sure SaintDraze is scum, and lynching him already would speed up the game. But, it never hurts to scumhunt more for second scum. And, other townies are also scumhunting, so stopping them would be untowny thing to do. Yea, it is boring as hell, but we want to practice scumhunting techniques and everything.
Here start his "I'm sure and game is over" attitude . He assumes that SaintDraze is already lynched so we should look for someone to make scapegoat of. We want to practice scumhunting, without asking any questions and looking for targets instead ? That's what you wanted to say ?
I don't know, I am horrible at hiding things. I don't really enjoy playing as scum. I can only guess.
Well, I would probably do some delicate scapegoating under false scumhunting, and I would try to vote for shortening. I would be trying to be active and pro-town, with some scumhunting and whatever. I would lie to myself about being townie, so I would appear in my mind as townie. Everything else would come somewhat natural then.
unvote SaintDraze, vote Supercharazad
Okay, you are rising as my main suspect. Can you explain why you are suspecting Jim - you have FoS-ed him - so quickly? I'm feeling something like chainsawing there...
Appeal to emotion with the good old "i would make the most obvious scumtells!' which he personally pointed as obvious in his previous posts. Of course divulging into WFIOM about scum plans is useless but luring us into easy situation illusion is not for scum.
Next his two post when asked for restating his reasons are just quoting his previous list. If it was to happen in a short period of time it wouldn't be problem, but if he doesn't change his reasons or add new ones - he just get tunnel-vision on his target, or just to limit possibility for scummy slip ?
...
Believe me, he is my second person on list. He is quite scummy. I could even provide more arguments than you why he can be scum. But you see, I can't really say that him annoying you was scummy or newby. He is your buddy, I suppose. So, he could be simply careless and was joking around for the hell of it. It's natural for him, I guess... It's not like I'm defending him. You are simply more suspicious than him.
Here we can see something strange : He could provide arguments "why he can be scum" not "why he is". That makes me think that you were aware that these arguments are false.Also it's not like changing your vote for town that looks more scummy at the moment is big deal for scum, right ?
What I am thinking? Vote SaintDraze. It seems he wasn't newby, but scummy. I was searching for some deeper meaning in his post, I don't know why. I had wifomed myself only. With Supercharazad death, I think it is really clear. I am terribly tired (4 hours of sleep, oh god), so I don't want to restate my thoughts on matter. I had posted them already. Well, after some sleep I can deliver it later if someone is really that interested.
Clear ? Yes, as if town death is 100% confirmation that someone he accused is scum. You jump from certain scum to newbie then back to certain scum on a whim apparently.
Uhh, I am being lazy prick. I am pretty sure of my scumpicks, so I don't bother to do anything besides observing if anybody does some weird things. I am losing quickly my interest when I'm getting easy win. With scums openly telling what they are... Meh.
Good Summary: Passive,lurky,certain of who is scum before lynch,tunnel-vision on, with easy scum win.
Most od D1 and D2 you were jumping around Super and SaintDraze case certain that one is worth lynching,of course just because they were town and were good targets not because they acted scummy. Unless you have split personality or lost your memory mid-game you seem to choose your vote based on current voting trend.
Author
Topic: Beginner's Mafia XXI - Game Over: Be Ashamed. Be Very Ashamed. (Read 56607 times)