Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Toaster]

Jim: Bastanormal, mostly.  It was a big issue there D1, and I thought I'd go with a straight up first post claim over any sort of hidden claim or drawn out thing.


Ottofar:  Now that is interesting.  Do you really think me scummy over it or are you blue texting me on principle?


Leafsnail:  Fair enough.  Unvote.


Argembarger:  Which type of mad scientist would you rather be if you were town?  Scum?

[Book]

Book, which alien do you think would be most interesting to play? (Also, I now think of Shepard Book anytime I see your name...)

Spore spreader, I think. I'd like to try that in principle, since I've never played a jester role. But I also like lasting through the end, so I don't think I'd like to be it more than once. And yes, the Shepherd is part of the charm of the name.

Booook, I got the impression in Supernatural 3 that the lessons you were going to take from the town loss were to be more irrationally paranoid about everything. If that's not the case, what did you take away from that game?

Certainly to up the paranoia, yes, but also to try and be less rigid/predictable. I found I tended to fall into common patterns, which could be abused by the scum and/or be detrimental to town, so I'll try to be a bit more experimental, and to question myself more.

Jim:  Sadly, Meph's script broke down and made me town this time.
However, it did make me a Kook, so that's something.

Interesting. Toaster, webadict and Janus: what do you think of the viability of claiming Kook right away as a scum tactic? We went through this during Bastardnormal, and I still think it's a ballsy but viable possibility.


Pandarsenic: What's your thought on third parties this game? We have 15 players and four dopps; do you think there's an Ext? Other aliens?

Org: If you were an Ext, who would you kill first?

MBP & Ottofar: If you were Kooks, would you claim on thread now, later in the game, on PM to someone, or not at all?

[Ottofar]

Toaster, I find two kooks unlikely.
Unless there's been a game with two before?

Zathras, I claimed already. I wouldn't have if Toaster hadn't. See above.

[Book]

Meph: I see Jim as voting me, not Toaster. Is it an error, or is there something funny going on with the voting?

The Whiteboard
Toaster: Jim Groovester

Book, as the exterminator, which techs would you pick?

I find the timing of your question interesting: are you an ext, looking for help in figuring out what to pick? I will leave your question unanswered, in case there is an Ext out there (whether it's you or not) I'd rather not assist with tech choices. Let him pick the lamest ones.

[Mephansteras]

The Whiteboard
Argembarger: Dariush, Leafsnail, Toaster
Book: Jim Groovester
Dariush: Jokerman-EXE
JanusTwoFace: webadict
Mysteriousbluepuppet: Ottofar
Org: JanusTwoFace
Toaster: Book


That should fix it.

Day ends ~5pm Pacific Monday

[Ottofar]

Why are there three people voting Argem?

[Jim Groovester]

Book, as the exterminator, which techs would you pick?

I find the timing of your question interesting: are you an ext, looking for help in figuring out what to pick? I will leave your question unanswered, in case there is an Ext out there (whether it's you or not) I'd rather not assist with tech choices. Let him pick the lamest ones.

Pfffft, this is lame. What's the point of asking RVS questions if you're just going to refuse to answer them?

If there is an Exterminator out there with half a brain he won't need your advice on it, and if he does need advice on tech choices he'll probably reveal himself in other ways. So just answer the question.

Ottofar, if you think two kooks are unlikely, why aren't you willing to vote Toaster over it?

[Toaster]

Book:  It's viable, but IMO it'd attract undue attention to you and put your base scumminess level up above most people, something I wouldn't want as scum.


Ottofar: Beware gambler's fallacy.  Para16 had two.

[Ottofar]

Because I'm not paying attention.

I'd blame that on Sleep Deprivation, having worked on a school project until 3am.

But yes,Unvote MBP
Vote Toaster.

PPE: It did?

Ah well. My vote's on you for now.
Sleep tim.

[Jim Groovester]

Because I'm not paying attention.

Mmmmmmmmmmmm, not buying it.

Not yet.

You paid enough attention to FoS him. You could've easily voted him instead.

[Book]

Zathras, I claimed already. I wouldn't have if Toaster hadn't. See above.

So I see. Yes, gambler's fallacy notwithstanding, I find it suspicious of both of you, though I think Toaster would be better at getting away with it as scum strategy.

Toaster: yes, extra attention is garnered, but as we saw in earlier games, if it can be withstood it leaves the person almost confirmed-townie and won't be inspected, which is an ideal position for a crafty scum.

Book, as the exterminator, which techs would you pick?

I find the timing of your question interesting: are you an ext, looking for help in figuring out what to pick? I will leave your question unanswered, in case there is an Ext out there (whether it's you or not) I'd rather not assist with tech choices. Let him pick the lamest ones.

Pfffft, this is lame. What's the point of asking RVS questions if you're just going to refuse to answer them? If there is an Exterminator out there with half a brain he won't need your advice on it, and if he does need advice on tech choices he'll probably reveal himself in other ways. So just answer the question.

No. Or at least, not yet. I don't give free advice to the enemy. If people are still interested, I'll answer this in as much detail as you want D2. In the mean time, if you think not answering this question hampers RVS, ask more questions.

[Jim Groovester]

Who the fuck is going to care about what tech choices you would've taken by Day 2?

It's a decent RVS question. Your refusal is bullshit. You have a problem with people getting reads on you? Because that's more important than whatever inconsequential speculation you make up.

Seriously, get over yourself. If there is an Exterminator I doubt he's going to be hanging on to your every word.

[Book]

Bite me.

But for the purposes of moving on... I'd pick Intel, and the EMP pulse emitter. Yeah, those would be awesome choices. If there's an Ext out there, he should pick that.

[Jim Groovester]

I'd vote you for your refusing to answer a question but I'm already voting you.

Everything worked out great!

[Toaster]

Ottofar:  You're voting me because I claimed Kook while you're already one, correct?  That's pretty flimsy reasoning.  I must say I find your "forgetting" to vote for me a lame excuse.


Zath:  Inspection can only go so far- that's what scum hunting is for.