Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  
Pages: 1 ... 37 38 [39] 40 41 ... 43

Author Topic: Beginner's Mafia XX - Game Over, Humanity Doomed!  (Read 129646 times)

Tyberix

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #570 on: February 16, 2011, 03:52:01 pm »

tyberix get active. who should be spared?
nincompoop same to you.
I know i deserve it but, using vote to prod at this stage of the game is a bit unnerving,and i could say it may be even scummy.. Not sure what you mean about sparing anyone,if who i think is least scummy then it was akhier but few of  lordincompoop arguments are worth considering and my TolyK investigation turned few interesting things too...

as you say, His Royal Townman Argembarger, Great Master and First and Principal Knight Grand Cross of the Most Honourable Order of the Bay12 Scumhunters.
...
ok then lets pick this apart some more:
Ahkier: Pulls out WIFOM and doesn't feel bad for it. This only confuses everyone and obfuscates the thread, making it easier for scum.
Has those useful up-to-date voting recors. I can't see any scum going through all the trouble of compiling them.
I could see really dedicated scum doing all that.
Quote
Tyberix: He does an impressive job of not getting noticed. Doesn't get too into the scumhunt, but he questions off the top.
I've actually not seen him ask many questions at all.
Quote
LNCP: He makes good point and seems to be the best scumhunter here, I doubt he's scummy.
Please show those points. I detect possible pairing.
This is not time for possibilities, we must be sure who we gonna lynch and why!

TolyK Are you sure you have anyone to attack or just jumping around aimlessly ?

After rereading the thread  i find some more of your disturbing habits :
1.Reactive behavior is good indicator of scum and what we have here ? Oh,right exactly that:
::)
waiting until something productive starts happening...

[...]

I haven't seen much to go on so far, and without concrete proof (read: corpse) I don't have much else to day. If something does happen I will jump right in.
[...]

posts please?
also feel free to question me.
Feeling guilty ?


2.Other slips :
[...]
***
Tyberix: it is scummy with supercharzard protecting himself through attacking attackers.
Same with lordnincompoop.


What I meant with that is folks lurking. nothing on them, and what currently is happening I've already worked out in my mind. in case you're wondering, I have a chart on paper of possible scumpals and keep updating. the current discussion isn't changing anything.
***
[...]
I thought it is basic way of town to prove his innocence,even with context of supercharazad? Also how it is possible that you got this all planned out,you know what your scumpartner is going to post or maybe you  know who is going to die at night ?

[...]
akhier has been very helpful, but that doesn't mean he's not scum. (sorry if you're town, but suspicion)
[...]
If you're scum you would know that he is ,apologizing him makes it sound like you're sure of it or maybe he's your scumpartner ?

Okay I am back on now...
Am I about to get lynched again?
Yep.
I actually don't remember if I'm voting for you or not :P
Unvote for now until I'm sure.
How important is you dieing, SaintDraze, to you?

 It would be very scummy approach to voting TolyK, even it it wasn't vote thrown on bandwagon. This way it's doubly suspicious.

[...]
I looked over the thread. also I took into consideration what people said about stuff happening, I noticed details I hadn't noticed before.
[...]
You're master of not saying anything substantial without saying that you got nothing... Also great way to avoid questions about your reasons..

[...]
chewie has indeed been posting quite a bit lately, but that could mean he's very dangerous scum too...
[...]
Another case of high number of posts = scum, i don't want to descend into Wifomy madness but that could be reason behind NKs...

3.On both D1 and D2 you promised to post your scumpick but never really delivered except simple list on everybody without real reasoning on person you found most scummy.

4.I could post here all your "paste quote and say understood" posts but it will take too much place...They bring NOTHING to the discussion except your try to look active and towny!

Summarizing: TolyK you avoid stating your direct suspects , assaulting even one person after attack on you, do not state your reason , eagearly jump on bandwagon (but in this case it's minor thing), tend to answer as vague as possible about your scumhunt. Also apparently you got some unjustified "town feel" about akhier which you periodically need to rephrase without real reason.
Let's say it clear you're scum Tolyk!
Logged

Akhier the Dragon hearted

  • Bay Watcher
  • I'm a Dragon, Roar
    • View Profile
    • My YouTube Channel
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #571 on: February 16, 2011, 04:58:56 pm »

Akhier, tell me how you are not scum. You haven't had an active role in any major lynching debate so far, nor put any pressure or interrogated anyone in a serious manner. Most of the posts you do tend to be statements, detailing your suspicions or token contribution in a discussion you seem not to want to be a part of.

This is exceedingly suspicious to me, and rings of a scum harbouring conflicting desires to both be active and stay inconspicuous. Additionally, your activeness toward the end of the game has diminished, showing a scum that has relaxed his game knowing the win that is to come.
   There has been NO lynching debate so far. All that has
happened is that someone messes up badly and everyone
goes "well he's scum" and vote for them. I just tried
putting pressure on you and yet
YOU   DID   NOT   ANSWER   MY   QUESTION   LORDNINCOMPOOP!


You've made a number of slips through out the game. This post is very suspicious:

   If Draze had not I would have actually. If you are good
at scum hunting what is to stop that from being good at
fake scum hunting. Once you are in the clear though you
would be someone to trust to properly hunt out the scum.

You openly admit to hunting good town, which goes directly against what this game is about. In pushing for good town lynches, you'd have a much easier time of winning the game as scum. It also shows very wishful thinking on your part, and is a rather blatant attempt to try to legitimise your actions and seem town-y by promising a resolution later.
   It went like this:
okay then I pick.... C.Darvi and his 'Stache Lordnincompoop and Tyberix...
both of you were scumhunting great...
Lordnincompoop&Tyberix:How many times have you questioned each other?
You're voting me because I'm good? What?

I'm pretty sure I questioned Tyberix quite a bit, just as much as the rest of you peeps. He's kinda invisible though, it's easy to forget.
   Then my quote you use. Do you know what I am
still waiting on? Your answer to his question of when
you question him seeing as you say you did it "quite a bit".


   Okay everybody, Starting now it is officially square one!
Everything you thought happened is now null and void so
there never was chewie or super. This is the only way out
of WIFOM death spiral.
Here, you try to do two things: One, establish your position of authority amongst the us so that your chances of getting lynched will decrease. Two, you try to hurt the town by discouraging us from using potentially vital information from the previous days. Not subtle enough, Akhier.
   Yes it was a bad thing to post and I appologized for
it and explained my reasoning:
   I misspoke about what I meant. The real meaning for
my words is that I want us to not consider chewie and
super at all except in terms of when someone talked to
them. Anyway even if we did reset right now as I said
with 2 less people the odds are better of hitting scum.
   We where going in rapidly tightening circles around
the meaning of chewies death so I was just like "well
then lets just not consider it" and back to square one
was the way I thought it through and not how it should
be done in reality.


[sarcasm]
   Darvi, nice of you to join us on this bandwagon so quickly
after I point out you had not voted!
[/sarcasm]

This is also suspicious, and very hypocritical to boot.  You criticise Darvi of bandwagonning almost immediately after you do so. You try to defame him at the same time you push the bandwagon toward the innocent town, pointing out his actions so that he may cover for your scumminess. To be a good town, it isn't enough to simply attack others for their mistakes; one must also obey the rules one sets. Here, you clearly have not done that.
   I was suspicious about the fact that only 2 people
had withheld any opionion at all then as soon as I pointed
it out one of them immediatly voted.


   Darvi: Monkey monkey apples frog,  applesauce. Frog
apples monkey frog monkey!

What the hell is this? Looks like scum trying to play the Jester card and relieve some of the pressure he's feeling.
   I actually trully really do say such things in real
life. I tend to repeat the words most of the time and
in general it will either be "monkey", "apples", "frog",
or "applesauce" so this is more of a leaking over. I
mostly did it because of what Darvi posted before that:
Tolyk: How old are you?

Yes, this is very relevant to the game, why do you ask? :P
   So I asked Darvi something very relevant in turn.


   Have any of you ever noticed that when you add
"technically" when you state a fact it sounds like your
lying. Technically I am not crazy!

There's a bunch of these spread out through the thread. As above, I'm suspecting scum playing Jester.

You are a confused scum, propelled in numerous directions by various forces. you try to be active but cannot, and you wish to lurk so as to remain inconspicuous. The result is a seemingly active player that posts much but says little. Now,  your lurking side seems to have come through. You are posting less and less as the game draws closer, when the town need to post the most.

PPE: Oh look posts.
   I try not to double post even though it is allowed
in Mafia because of the no edit rule. In the begining
this was easy because it was very active but in the last
few days very few people have been posting, in fact it
has been so sparse the Mod asks if we where going to
play or if he should just rage-modkill everyone.



Akhier: How many times do you want to carry on with no own investigation ? Another time you jumped on bus - no explanation,no questions - just go on with the bus. And by accident (or not?) both times it ended with dead town.
...
Claiming your newbieness is never an adequate reason. See what you did wrong, then correct it. Don't try to explain it, you just look scummy for doing it.
   You where the one to first mention the time I went
wrong so how was I supposed to go about it? You specifically
called me out on it.

...
   Sorry if something I said confused you. If I do so again
ask me and I probably can tell you what I actually meant.
I wine because someone hid the Mountain Dew on me. Once
I figure where everything is and how it is supposed to go
I will be less of a drunk.
What the hell? You make no sense.
   I was meaning that I am new at the game so what
I say will be confusing sometimes. If I am being confusing
call me out on it to explain.

Spoiler: Dead Townies (click to show/hide)
Logged
Quote
Join us. The crazy is at a perfect temperature today.
So it seems I accidentally put my canteen in my wheelbarrow and didn't notice... and then I got really thirsty... so right before going to sleep I go to take a swig from my canteen and... end up snorting a line of low-grade meth.

Argembarger

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
    • Not quite yet
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #572 on: February 16, 2011, 06:28:18 pm »

Mistake-fix

//  /*--------------------------------------------------------*\
//  |   BM-XX Voting Terminal - Day 3
//  |*--------------------------------------------------------*|
//  |   
//  |   TolyK (2) - Zrk2, Tyberix
//  |   Tyberix (1) - TolyK
//  |   Akhier the Dragon hearted (1) - lordnincompoop
//  |   lordnincompoop (1) - Akhier the Dragon hearted
//  |
//  |   Not voting (0)
//  |   
//  |   Extend (0)
//  |   2 players required to extend/shorten
//  |   
//  |   Day 3 Ends: Thursday, February 17 @ 10:00 PM EST
//  |   
//  \*--------------------------------------------------------*/
Logged
Quote from: penguinofhonor
Quote from: miauw62
This guy needs to write a biography about Columbus. I would totally buy it.
I can see it now.

trying to make a different's: the life of Columbus

lordnincompoop

  • Bay Watcher
  • Allusionist
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #573 on: February 16, 2011, 07:12:15 pm »

Akhier, tell me how you are not scum. You haven't had an active role in any major lynching debate so far, nor put any pressure or interrogated anyone in a serious manner. Most of the posts you do tend to be statements, detailing your suspicions or token contribution in a discussion you seem not to want to be a part of.

This is exceedingly suspicious to me, and rings of a scum harbouring conflicting desires to both be active and stay inconspicuous. Additionally, your activeness toward the end of the game has diminished, showing a scum that has relaxed his game knowing the win that is to come.
   There has been NO lynching debate so far. All that has
happened is that someone messes up badly and everyone
goes "well he's scum" and vote for them. I just tried
putting pressure on you and yet
YOU   DID   NOT   ANSWER   MY   QUESTION   LORDNINCOMPOOP!

Yes, there has been. It's all around you, and it's discussion. You should have taken a more active role in it.

What question is this that you are referring to? I see no such question.

You've made a number of slips through out the game. This post is very suspicious:

You openly admit to hunting good town, which goes directly against what this game is about. In pushing for good town lynches, you'd have a much easier time of winning the game as scum. It also shows very wishful thinking on your part, and is a rather blatant attempt to try to legitimise your actions and seem town-y by promising a resolution later.
   It went like this:
okay then I pick.... C.Darvi and his 'Stache Lordnincompoop and Tyberix...
both of you were scumhunting great...
Lordnincompoop&Tyberix:How many times have you questioned each other?
You're voting me because I'm good? What?

I'm pretty sure I questioned Tyberix quite a bit, just as much as the rest of you peeps. He's kinda invisible though, it's easy to forget.
   Then my quote you use. Do you know what I am
still waiting on? Your answer to his question of when
you question him seeing as you say you did it "quite a bit".

This is a non-answer and you know it. We're discussing your pushes for town lynches, not contexts for quotes or questions unanswered.

I'm sure you can give the thread another read-through for the posts. Additionally, in an attack the burden of proof is on you; it is your responsibility to find evidence and convict, not mine.

Here, you try to do two things: One, establish your position of authority amongst the us so that your chances of getting lynched will decrease. Two, you try to hurt the town by discouraging us from using potentially vital information from the previous days. Not subtle enough, Akhier.
   Yes it was a bad thing to post and I appologized for
it and explained my reasoning:
   I misspoke about what I meant. The real meaning for
my words is that I want us to not consider chewie and
super at all except in terms of when someone talked to
them. Anyway even if we did reset right now as I said
with 2 less people the odds are better of hitting scum.
   We where going in rapidly tightening circles around
the meaning of chewies death so I was just like "well
then lets just not consider it" and back to square one
was the way I thought it through and not how it should
be done in reality.

This to me does not adequately resolve the situation. It sounds like you've made a scumslip and hastily cobbled up an excuse to cover it up. What are you even trying to say? That we should ignore the impact that Super and Chewie have made? That we should ignore the questions and reactions that super and cheiwe posted and recieved? That we should simply ignore their deaths?

You're reiterating what you said earlier. And if it is the last, you're still left with an unclear, hasty correction and a null post. Why are you repeating something that was already established and implemented, then? It does no good, and you wasted precious time.

What the hell is this? Looks like scum trying to play the Jester card and relieve some of the pressure he's feeling.
   I actually trully really do say such things in real
life. I tend to repeat the words most of the time and
in general it will either be "monkey", "apples", "frog",
or "applesauce" so this is more of a leaking over. I
mostly did it because of what Darvi posted before that:
Tolyk: How old are you?

Yes, this is very relevant to the game, why do you ask? :P
   So I asked Darvi something very relevant in turn.

That still does not change it. Darvi's question was legitimate or at least coherent, whilst yours was not. Silly questions are useless as well, and if you find one you should point it out or admonish him, not make one of your own and clog up the thread.

   I try not to double post even though it is allowed
in Mafia because of the no edit rule. In the begining
this was easy because it was very active but in the last
few days very few people have been posting, in fact it
has been so sparse the Mod asks if we where going to
play or if he should just rage-modkill everyone.

This is an awful excuse. Double posting should not stop you from participating in a thread. If in a period of inactivity, don't just wait for another post to appear; take the initiative and make another.

D2 was, in my opinion, plenty active. It's curious though how it just stopped.
Logged

Akhier the Dragon hearted

  • Bay Watcher
  • I'm a Dragon, Roar
    • View Profile
    • My YouTube Channel
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #574 on: February 16, 2011, 07:26:23 pm »

   lordnincompoop: how do you feel that your team is
doing so far? Tell us how you feel about the game
please.
   Also double posting to participate only works if others
are participating as well. I could have filled a couple pages
with my talking to myself but with no one else saying
anything it is no good at all. It takes 2 to tango buster.
Logged
Quote
Join us. The crazy is at a perfect temperature today.
So it seems I accidentally put my canteen in my wheelbarrow and didn't notice... and then I got really thirsty... so right before going to sleep I go to take a swig from my canteen and... end up snorting a line of low-grade meth.

lordnincompoop

  • Bay Watcher
  • Allusionist
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #575 on: February 17, 2011, 05:48:19 am »

   lordnincompoop: how do you feel that your team is
doing so far? Tell us how you feel about the game
please.
   Also double posting to participate only works if others
are participating as well. I could have filled a couple pages
with my talking to myself but with no one else saying
anything it is no good at all. It takes 2 to tango buster.

   lordnincompoop: how do you feel that your team is
doing so far? Tell us how you feel about the game
please.

What team? If you mean town, then I though we'd be in a better situation by now.

I am enjoying this game. It's been very active, and it's very fun playing. Perhaps some more posts at LYLO.

You've addressed only one of my points so far, and it's one of the minor ones. You're being so quiet, Akhier.
Logged

Akhier the Dragon hearted

  • Bay Watcher
  • I'm a Dragon, Roar
    • View Profile
    • My YouTube Channel
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #576 on: February 17, 2011, 07:03:41 am »

   Sorry I did not see your second post. The one I answered
is only minor if the longer something is the more minor it is
because the one I was so long as to hide your second post.

   As for the question I did not ask you to tell us your team
at all but the fact you had to hesitate and ask if I meant
town where the other person I asked this question to
anwered like so:
   SaintDraze: Tell me how you think the game is going
for your team so far. In detail please.
Not very good since whatever benefit we got from lynching super we no doubt lost from chewie getting NKed
and he was town. Also by quiet what do you mean! You and
me are the only players to post in the last 14 hours and with this post you
and me both have the same number of posts.
Logged
Quote
Join us. The crazy is at a perfect temperature today.
So it seems I accidentally put my canteen in my wheelbarrow and didn't notice... and then I got really thirsty... so right before going to sleep I go to take a swig from my canteen and... end up snorting a line of low-grade meth.

Akhier the Dragon hearted

  • Bay Watcher
  • I'm a Dragon, Roar
    • View Profile
    • My YouTube Channel
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #577 on: February 17, 2011, 07:05:02 am »

   And boom, I now have 4 posts to your 3 posts in the
last 14 hours, does that mean I am more active then you?
Logged
Quote
Join us. The crazy is at a perfect temperature today.
So it seems I accidentally put my canteen in my wheelbarrow and didn't notice... and then I got really thirsty... so right before going to sleep I go to take a swig from my canteen and... end up snorting a line of low-grade meth.

lordnincompoop

  • Bay Watcher
  • Allusionist
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #578 on: February 17, 2011, 07:28:25 am »

   As for the question I did not ask you to tell us your team
at all but the fact you had to hesitate and ask if I meant
town where the other person I asked this question to
anwered like so:
   SaintDraze: Tell me how you think the game is going
for your team so far. In detail please.
Not very good since whatever benefit we got from lynching super we no doubt lost from chewie getting NKed and he was town.

What hesitation? I wanted something clarified, so I asked. Was that not what you wanted?

Also by quiet what do you mean! You and
me are the only players to post in the last 14 hours and with this post you
and me both have the same number of posts.

   And boom, I now have 4 posts to your 3 posts in the
last 14 hours, does that mean I am more active then you?

That's quite a reaction to a simple remark, isn't it?

Simply because everyone else is quiet(er) doesn't mean you are not. I haven't seen you make a single attack or non-defensive post this whole day, and the only vote you have made is little more than an OMGUS thrown in the heat.
Logged

lordnincompoop

  • Bay Watcher
  • Allusionist
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #579 on: February 17, 2011, 07:29:21 am »

Bluh quote tags. Fixed:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Logged

Tyberix

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #580 on: February 17, 2011, 07:31:51 am »

   Sorry I did not see your second post. The one I answered
is only minor if the longer something is the more minor it is
because the one I was so long as to hide your second post.
Akhier you attack him for posting long evidence ? And since when that's bad thing ?

Also lordincompoop
I'm sure you can give the thread another read-through for the posts. Additionally, in an attack the burden of proof is on you; it is your responsibility to find evidence and convict, not mine.

If not finding evidence then what is your responsibility ? I thought that's what town do,unless you're scum ?

Well i'm still stand by my vote if you ask of my activity
Logged

Akhier the Dragon hearted

  • Bay Watcher
  • I'm a Dragon, Roar
    • View Profile
    • My YouTube Channel
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #581 on: February 17, 2011, 07:34:35 am »

   lordnincompoop, I have been attacking you sir. I am
going with you are scum and I believe this because of
a number of things that have been brought up. You as
well have been attacking Me so do not try that. You
are voting for me and I am voting for you and this is
the most actual debate on lynching the whole game.
Logged
Quote
Join us. The crazy is at a perfect temperature today.
So it seems I accidentally put my canteen in my wheelbarrow and didn't notice... and then I got really thirsty... so right before going to sleep I go to take a swig from my canteen and... end up snorting a line of low-grade meth.

Akhier the Dragon hearted

  • Bay Watcher
  • I'm a Dragon, Roar
    • View Profile
    • My YouTube Channel
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #582 on: February 17, 2011, 07:36:08 am »

   Sorry I did not see your second post. The one I answered
is only minor if the longer something is the more minor it is
because the one I was so long as to hide your second post.
Akhier you attack him for posting long evidence ? And since when that's bad thing ?
   I am not attacking him for having long evidence. I simply
said that I did not see the second post under the first post
which was long.
Logged
Quote
Join us. The crazy is at a perfect temperature today.
So it seems I accidentally put my canteen in my wheelbarrow and didn't notice... and then I got really thirsty... so right before going to sleep I go to take a swig from my canteen and... end up snorting a line of low-grade meth.

TolyK

  • Bay Watcher
  • Nowan Ilfideme
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #583 on: February 17, 2011, 07:57:31 am »

You answered. Unvote.
tyberix get active. who should be spared?
nincompoop same to you.
I know i deserve it but, using vote to prod at this stage of the game is a bit unnerving,and i could say it may be even scummy..
I certainly don't feel that way. When I'm inactive I get what I deserve: people shouting my name, threatening to kill me if I don't show up and talk.

Quote
Not sure what you mean about sparing anyone,if who i think is least scummy then it was akhier but few of  lordincompoop arguments are worth considering and my TolyK investigation turned few interesting things too...
Oh, let's see...
Quote
ok then lets pick this apart some more:
Ahkier: Pulls out WIFOM and doesn't feel bad for it. This only confuses everyone and obfuscates the thread, making it easier for scum.
Has those useful up-to-date voting recors. I can't see any scum going through all the trouble of compiling them.
I could see really dedicated scum doing all that.
Quote
Tyberix: He does an impressive job of not getting noticed. Doesn't get too into the scumhunt, but he questions off the top.
I've actually not seen him ask many questions at all.
Quote
LNCP: He makes good point and seems to be the best scumhunter here, I doubt he's scummy.
Please show those points. I detect possible pairing.
This is not time for possibilities, we must be sure who we gonna lynch and why!
You mean we should just get it over with? ScumCounter++
Quote
TolyK Are you sure you have anyone to attack or just jumping around aimlessly ?
It's fairly hard to decide who to attack. I want more answers from multiple people.
Quote
After rereading the thread  i find some more of your disturbing habits :
1.Reactive behavior is good indicator of scum and what we have here ? Oh,right exactly that:
::)
waiting until something productive starts happening...
"I don't see anything interesting in terms of new posts. I've gotten stuff and haven't got more."
Quote
[...]

I haven't seen much to go on so far, and without concrete proof (read: corpse) I don't have much else to day. If something does happen I will jump right in.
[...]
... yeah, and I did, didn't I?
Quote
posts please?
also feel free to question me.
Feeling guilty ?
What. I'm asking folks to question me so I could see what folks want. Questions are great for finding potential scum-slips.
Oh, and thanks for the questions BTW.
Quote
2.Other slips :
[...]
***
Tyberix: it is scummy with supercharzard protecting himself through attacking attackers.
Same with lordnincompoop.

What I meant with that is folks lurking. nothing on them, and what currently is happening I've already worked out in my mind. in case you're wondering, I have a chart on paper of possible scumpals and keep updating. the current discussion isn't changing anything.
***
[...]
I thought it is basic way of town to prove his innocence,even with context of supercharazad?
Maybe. However it seems that someone may have known he was innocent? ScumCounter++
Quote
Also how it is possible that you got this all planned out,you know what your scumpartner is going to post or maybe you  know who is going to die at night ?
If a person I (unsuccessfully) try to lynch gets nightkilled, I'd be surprised.
My "plan" is a network of possible relations. I would take a picture of it on paper, but my camera is currently with a friend.
Quote
[...]
akhier has been very helpful, but that doesn't mean he's not scum. (sorry if you're town, but suspicion)
[...]
If you're scum you would know that he is ,apologizing him makes it sound like you're sure of it or maybe he's your scumpartner ?
please explain this. I've reread it 5 times and still haven't got it. If he was "my scumpartner", why would I say the stuff in italics above to him?
Quote
Okay I am back on now...
Am I about to get lynched again?
Yep.
I actually don't remember if I'm voting for you or not :P
Unvote for now until I'm sure.
How important is you dieing, SaintDraze, to you?

 It would be very scummy approach to voting TolyK, even it it wasn't vote thrown on bandwagon. This way it's doubly suspicious.
That... wasn't voting maybe? He was gonna die anyway and I wanted to possibly get other targets. Also, how would it be "doubly suspicious"?
Quote
[...]
I looked over the thread. also I took into consideration what people said about stuff happening, I noticed details I hadn't noticed before.
[...]
You're master of not saying anything substantial without saying that you got nothing... Also great way to avoid questions about your reasons..
That was a post I wrote late in the night, I meant to say something in the morning but forgot.
Quote
[...]
chewie has indeed been posting quite a bit lately, but that could mean he's very dangerous scum too...
[...]
Another case of high number of posts = scum, i don't want to descend into Wifomy madness but that could be reason behind NKs...
Exactly my thoughts.

Quote
3.On both D1 and D2 you promised to post your scumpick but never really delivered except simple list on everybody without real reasoning on person you found most scummy.
That's because I'm horrible with contrete reason  :P in
Quote
4.I could post here all your "paste quote and say understood" posts but it will take too much place...They bring NOTHING to the discussion except your try to look active and towny!
Uh, I was saying that I got their question and have nothing from their posts to use against them.
Quote
Summarizing: TolyK you avoid stating your direct suspects , assaulting even one person after attack on you, do not state your reason , eagearly jump on bandwagon (but in this case it's minor thing), tend to answer as vague as possible about your scumhunt. Also apparently you got some unjustified "town feel" about akhier which you periodically need to rephrase without real reason.
the bold: what the hell? where did you get any of those from? akhier hasn't posted anything I considered scummy As Of Your Post (I got ninja'd...) and so I have less reason to think he's scum. you are contradicting yourself, saying that I don't assault then saying I assault everyone? ScumCounter++
the italics: yes. this is because this game has me very confused and there's no complete bait. whoever is scum is doing it very well.
Quote
Let's say it clear you're scum Tolyk!
... you may be in a glass case, but that glass is green.  ;)
...
Ninja'd by Akheir and Co., let me see...
Logged
My Mafia Stats
just do whatevery tolyK and blame it as a bastard mod
Shakerag: Who are you personally suspicious of?
At this point?  TolyK.

lordnincompoop

  • Bay Watcher
  • Allusionist
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia XX - Day 3: Darvi's blood spills
« Reply #584 on: February 17, 2011, 08:00:21 am »

Also lordincompoop
I'm sure you can give the thread another read-through for the posts. Additionally, in an attack the burden of proof is on you; it is your responsibility to find evidence and convict, not mine.

If not finding evidence then what is your responsibility ? I thought that's what town do,unless you're scum ?

Well i'm still stand by my vote if you ask of my activity

It is not my responsibility to find evidence for others' attacks directed at myself. That is the responsibility of the attacker.

My responsibility is to find my own evidence for my own attacks and use them in hunting scum, as should be everyone's responsibility.

lordnincompoop, I have been attacking you sir. I am going with you are scum and I believe this because of a number of things that have been brought up.

I read through your posts. They are without a doubt defense-oriented. The only reason you've voted for me was because you happened to overlook an answer I wrote.

You as well have been attacking Me so do not try that. You are voting for me and I am voting for you and this is the most actual debate on lynching the whole game.

I'm having a bit of a problem understanding what you're saying here, because of the lack of context. Are you referring to the OMGUS?

I don't see where my attack on you has anything to do with any of this. I believe I bring up good points, and so far you haven't made any in your counter. Your vote, as I see it, is an OMGUS.

You know, maybe I should have made a shippingscumchart. Ah well, Next time.
Logged
Pages: 1 ... 37 38 [39] 40 41 ... 43