You really should get involved with the
Games Threshold Discussion and List.
Another reason that your games aren't filling is that you're an unknown quantity. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but it does mean that people won't be as quick to join your games. And with how few people there are to begin with, it means they might not fill at all.
Comments / questions:
Okay, so the idea is to play a Dwarf Fortress-themed mafia game.
Been done, but it's been a while.
This is split into "day" and "night" stages. During the "day" stage folks decide who to hang use justice on, if anyone. Then during the night the mafia disguised elves go and kill someone they choose. At the same time, most professions such as the policeman observer, psycho "doctor" and doctors militia do their work. I'll assume you know the different professions, if you don't just ask.[/spoiler]
We all know how Mafia in general works. The problem is in the details. Will days be based on time (if so, how long?) or will lynches be Hammer-based?
You also leave a lot of other common rules out. Are PMs allowed? More details on ties? What about No-lynching votes? Tied votes? Speaking after being lynched? Nightkilled?
Legendary Miner/Woodcutter/Lye maker... - citizen immune to hanging
Seems like it could be overpowerul. If they (fail) to get lynched, you have an instant certified town center. Combine that with the Doctor and you have a 5/6 chance per day of even protecting him.
Hammerer (Me) - the guy that deals out "justice" with a silver/platinum war hammer; immune to death
Does this mean you're actually playing? (As in you have a vote / will comment on things?) It's ambiguous.
Goblin (Hidden) - mafia #2
Does this mean that you will have two mafias?
Headmaster(s) (Hidden) - has 2x vote on killing, kills anyone who meets him during the night
Is this an Elf role? Or a Dwarf role? If a Dwarf role, how is it anti-town?
Doctor (Hidden) - Psychopath drunk doctor that either protects or kills a person during the night (killing 1 or 6 out on 1d6)
Could be used to protect the Legendary Dwarf (at least with good chance). Again, is still mostly a more town role than anti-town.