Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[TolyK]

Zrk2 So your definition of "contributing" is throwing random votes which, changing them after nearly blank post ? Maybe i'm not the best scumhunter but using the same excuse for self-defense along with admit that you have no clear suspects is confusing at least..

Agreed.

[...]
Ottofar, a very good question.
That's the point of this game 
You could try lynching whoever didn't consider the doc to be lynched...

TolyK So it makes no difference to you who do we lynch?

Uh...
I am just using reverse psychology. people who didn't look at who they may have thought was the doctor to be lynched may have wanted him to be killed at night instead.

[Zrk2]

Votecount please.

[Darvi]

I don't think anybody has voted yet. Has anyone?

[Zrk2]

NO, looks like just me, for Ottofar, for his cryptic way of saying he wanted to lynch me. He always wants to lynch me.
Mukluk Detail your scumpicks and why.

[Ottofar]

NO, looks like just me, for Ottofar, for his cryptic way of saying he wanted to lynch me. He always wants to lynch me.

What.

[Argembarger]

//  /*--------------------------------------------------------*\
//  |   Beginner's Mafia XIX Whiteboard - Day 2
//  |*--------------------------------------------------------*|
//  |   Zrk2 (1) - Ottofar
//  |   Darvi (1) - Tyberix
//  |   Ottofar (1) - Zrk2
//  |
//  |   Not Voting (4) - Azure Sepulchre, TolyK, mukluk, Darvi
//  |   
//  |   No extension/shorten requests
//  |   Two more extensions remaining for Day 2
//  |   3 players required to extend/shorten
//  |   
//  |   Day Ends: Tuesday, January 25, 2011 @ 10:00 PM EST
//  |   
//  \*--------------------------------------------------------

[Darvi]

So, Tolyk, who do you think we shouldn't lynch?

[TolyK]

So, Tolyk, who do you think we shouldn't lynch?

Ottofar and zrk2 have voted for each other. Unless they're REALLY smart they can't be same-aligned.

But who?

[Darvi]

Hmm, Zrk2 has asked a lot of questions, while Ottofar has answered quite a few questions by quoting himself quoting other people quoting himself (or something like that).

Now, if Zrk2 were scum, then all of that questioning was a ruse to make us think he's a very inquisitive townie, and Ottofar, being an actual townie, just gave a lot of cryptic answers that nobody understood.
If the opposite were true, then Ottofar has made a (hardly subtle) attempt at confusing us, while Zrk2 really is very inquisitive.

[TolyK]

Darvi, Exactly.

Now, it seems that Ottofar is trying to confuse us. While zrk2 is trying to stop people from finding out who he is.

My notation is : Mafia=1, Townie=0.

If Ottofar=1 and Zrk2 = 1 then they are trying to trick us into thinking one of them is the townie.
If Ottofar=1 and Zrk2 = 0 then Ottofar is rightfully being confusing and Zrk2 is a special dude (cop?)
If Ottofar=0 and Zrk2 = 1 then Ottofar is naturally cryptic/lazy and Zrk2 is trying to look like a townie.
If Ottofar=0 and Zrk2 = 0 then they're both bad mafia players.

[Darvi]

Darvi, Exactly.

Now, it seems that Ottofar is trying to confuse us. While zrk2 is trying to stop people from finding out who he is.

My notation is : Mafia=1, Townie=0.

If Ottofar=1 and Zrk2 = 1 then they are trying to trick us into thinking one of them is the townie.
If Ottofar=1 and Zrk2 = 0 then Ottofar is rightfully being confusing and Zrk2 is a special dude (cop?)
If Ottofar=0 and Zrk2 = 1 then Ottofar is naturally cryptic/lazy and Zrk2 is trying to look like a townie.
If Ottofar=0 and Zrk2 = 0 then they're both bad mafia players.

Well (0,0) is out of the question imo. Just my guts though.
(1,1) would be bad for them, since they're actively trying to frame each other, meaning that in the end there's one less of them left.
(1,0) is somewhat unlikely, since it's blatantly confusing. Unless he counts on reverse psychology.
So... (0,1) it is then?

[TolyK]

Darvi, Exactly.

Now, it seems that Ottofar is trying to confuse us. While zrk2 is trying to stop people from finding out who he is.

My notation is : Mafia=1, Townie=0.

If Ottofar=1 and Zrk2 = 1 then they are trying to trick us into thinking one of them is the townie.
If Ottofar=1 and Zrk2 = 0 then Ottofar is rightfully being confusing and Zrk2 is a special dude (cop?)
If Ottofar=0 and Zrk2 = 1 then Ottofar is naturally cryptic/lazy and Zrk2 is trying to look like a townie.
If Ottofar=0 and Zrk2 = 0 then they're both bad mafia players.

Well (0,0) is out of the question imo. Just my guts though.
(1,1) would be bad for them, since they're actively trying to frame each other, meaning that in the end there's one less of them left.
(1,0) is somewhat unlikely, since it's blatantly confusing. Unless he counts on reverse psychology.
So... (0,1) it is then?

(0,0) yeah.
(1,1) well but then one of them is framed as a townie. Which helps them.
(1,0) agreed
(0,1) probably.

Wow, logical deduction in a game based on gut feeling.
Wow.

Zrk2 it is then.

[Darvi]

Ya, but then somebody still might say "Hey, lets kill him anyway!". And they lose one vote for lynching townies. Doesn't matter for this round though because if that's true then we're guaranteed to kill one scum.

And you do know that we're likely the next to be killed by the mafia, right? Eh, anything for our dark lord I suppose.

Zrk2

[TolyK]

We are too smart to live.
Well that was fun knowing ya!

[Darvi]

Eh, I've prepared for that eventuality.