Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Argembarger]

//  /*--------------------------------------------------------*\
//  |   Beginner's Mafia XIX Whiteboard - Day 1
//  |*--------------------------------------------------------*|
//  |   
//  |   UristMcDwarf (1) - Azure Sepulchre
//  |   Zrk2 (1) - Ottofar
//  |   TolyK (1) - Zrk2
//  |   No Lynch (1) - TolyK
//  |
//  |   Not Voting (5) - UristMcDwarf, Tyberix, mukluk, Darvi, The Captain
//  |   
//  |   No extension/shorten requests
//  |   3 players required to extend/shorten
//  |   
//  |   Day Ends: Thursday, January 20, 2011 @ 10:00 PM EST
//  |   (Around 9.5 hours from now)
//  |   
//  \*--------------------------------------------------------*/

[Darvi]

Urist McDwarf.

But I'll keep an eye on zrk2

[TolyK]

well that's nice I'm being elected as mayor 
(I'm just kidding.)
I wonder what zrk2 is going by. The fact that I *may* have gotten vadia's character and he seemed like mafia?

We shall see...
Pre-post edit: NOOO I MUST RULE AS MAYOR!

[Ottofar]

Extension requested.

[Darvi]

Three hours left

[TolyK]

Extension requested.

supported. 4 voted 5 left? just thinking opinions....

[Darvi]

Yeah let's give the others a chance.

>request extension

[mukluk]

OK then
I vote for no-lynch. but zrk2 is suspicious. too vague.
tell us exactly the who and the what.

Is no-lynch an option because I thought you either vote for someone or unvote a previous vote?

[Toaster]

You can specifically vote for a no-lynch.  If one person votes for someone and the other eight don't vote, then that one person will be lynched.  If the other eight voted for no-lynch instead, there would be no lynch.


The idea of a no-lynch on the first day may sound appealing at first, but in the long run it is unhelpful.  Even if a townie is lynched, you can read into the pattern of votes on that person to try to determine who is scum.  I do not advise using that as a sole basis for determining scum (even town can make an honest mistake), but it gives you something to go on.  If you no-lynch on the first day, you're right back where you were to start with on day two, except there is one less town member.

On that note, I generally advise against speculating as to why a person was killed.  The scum team could have picked someone who threatened them, yes, but they also could have picked at random.  I have in the past as scum targeted someone simply because they were innocuous.  The choice of NK target is a poor source of info.


If you have specific questions, feel free to ask me here in the thread- that's what I'm here for.

[Azure Sepulchre]

I second that motion for an extension, which gives us a majority. Cool beans and ting.

[Tyberix]

Sure, extension is welcome.

On more important matter: Is this some kind of of provocation Urist McDwarf? It really make me wonder if this was meant as a real vote..

mukluk Do asking no questions/semi-lurking help you achieve your scummy objectives ?

[Argembarger]

//  /*--------------------------------------------------------*\
//  |   Beginner's Mafia XIX Whiteboard - Day 1
//  |*--------------------------------------------------------*|
//  |   
//  |   UristMcDwarf (2) - Azure Sepulchre, Darvi
//  |   Zrk2 (1) - Ottofar
//  |   TolyK (1) - Zrk2
//  |   No Lynch (1) - TolyK
//  |
//  |   Not Voting (4) - UristMcDwarf, Tyberix, mukluk, The Captain
//  |   
//  |   5 extension/shorten requests - Extension Passed!
//  |   One more extension remaining for Day 1
//  |   3 players required to extend/shorten
//  |   
//  |   Day Ends: Friday, January 21, 2011 @ 10:00 PM EST
//  |   
//  \*--------------------------------------------------------*/

[mukluk]

You can specifically vote for a no-lynch.  If one person votes for someone and the other eight don't vote, then that one person will be lynched.  If the other eight voted for no-lynch instead, there would be no lynch.


The idea of a no-lynch on the first day may sound appealing at first, but in the long run it is unhelpful.  Even if a townie is lynched, you can read into the pattern of votes on that person to try to determine who is scum.  I do not advise using that as a sole basis for determining scum (even town can make an honest mistake), but it gives you something to go on.  If you no-lynch on the first day, you're right back where you were to start with on day two, except there is one less town member.

On that note, I generally advise against speculating as to why a person was killed.  The scum team could have picked someone who threatened them, yes, but they also could have picked at random.  I have in the past as scum targeted someone simply because they were innocuous.  The choice of NK target is a poor source of info.


If you have specific questions, feel free to ask me here in the thread- that's what I'm here for.

Okay thanks for the info Toaster.

[mukluk]

Sure, extension is welcome.

mukluk Do asking no questions/semi-lurking help you achieve your scummy objectives ?

I'm new to this whole questioning thing and isn't "lurking" how everyone keep up with the game?  I agree an extension will give us more time to catch mafia.

[Toaster]

I'm new to this whole questioning thing and isn't "lurking" how everyone keep up with the game?

Lurking is when you refrain from posting.  Active lurking is when you post without contributing.  Neither are considered town-friendly, because you're not participating in the scum hunting process.  You need to be able to not only keep up to date with what is going on, but also probe other players to determine for yourself who is honest and who is a lying dirty scumbag.