NOTE: Useful is defined as what I see as useful. Post counts are probably slightly off, I counted them by hand.
6 posts, 4 useful
#28 - RV response without scumhunting
#18 - Self proclaimed lurker, scum or at least anti-town
#112 - Third vote on MBP-wagon
Has been surprisingly useful for PFP. Promised more later (see later), but hasn't delivered. Would like a nice solid post. Leaning town.
12 posts, 10 useful
#118 - Vote, unvote, vote in the same post; looking for scumteams rather than individuals
Don't think he's scum. Annoying when tunneling me Day 1, but not particularly scummy.
6 posts, 2 useful
#187 - First content of the game, broken quotes and confusing wording, seems to suspect Zathras and me both (scumteam hunting)
#199 - Backtracks on previous confusing post
Missing and then confusing as hell. Leaning scum, but might be biased in that regard.
6 posts, 6 useful
#84 - Sounds like knew new MBP'd flip town
#102 - Suspiciously specific comment about third parties, possible third party himself?
Gut feeling says he's third party. Quieter than I'd like, but not unsually so.
18 posts, 18 useful
Same as always. Can never find anything scummy about him.
6 posts, 5 useful
#53 - Attacking Org (like herding cats), slightly scummy in it being only Org
Mostly 'useful' posts, but feels like active lurking. He's been more active in past games. Leaning towards scum.
16 posts, 15 useful
Seems angry, but not particularly scummy. Leaning town.
5 posts, 4 useful
#19 - Hypocritical on seriousness of RV questions
#103 - Wants to be scum so he "doesn't feel bad" getting lynched Day 1
#168 - Blue candy for saying I've been quiet (after I posted why)
Angry, which is par for the course. Don't think I've played a game with him when he was both town and angry. Leaning towards scum.
5 posts, 0 useful
#101 - Over angry, second post with no scumhunting
Useless. He's done the same before, he'll do it again. Bet he'll claim he got bored if pushed on it.
11 posts, 10 useful
I usually have more on him even when he's town. Been making some pretty decent points, more than normal. Leaning town.
27 posts, 22 useful
#41 - Admitted lurker, wants to jump on bandwagons
#70 - Too hesitant
#73 - Keeps a backup plan, looks like lining up lynches
#78 - Backs down too quickly
Hesitent and bandwagony. Betting he's just new to B12's mafia style. leaning town.