Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Deus ex Machina]

The awesome-looking Morrowind 2011 mod collection has been taken off line following complaints and threats of legal action from several of the original mod authors.

On January 3, we pointed you at Morrowind 2011, a massive, 4GB collection of Morrowind mods assembled by Tyler Smith of Alberta, who also whipped up a painfully detailed guide for making all the mods work together without blowing anything up. He wrote on the his Wordpress site that he was a little concerned that some mod authors might not be happy about being included in his compendium, although he added, "I do care about them [and] I have included a credits file in the zip."

His worry turned out to be very well-founded. The day after the mod collection was turned over to the public, Smith said he began to receive complaints and threats of legal action from various mod authors along with demands that he take the package offline. He was also banned and IP blocked from Bethesda's Morrowind forums.

"I was kind of expecting some response but the head-hunting part was a bit more extreme than I was expecting," Smith said. He added that he was in the process of updating the credits in the mod collection but said that the complainants weren't interested in "reaching a middle ground."

That jibes with an email he received from one aggrieved mod author, who said that the list of credits is largely irrelevant. "The bottom line is that your compilation violates copyright law in about a dozen countries and a vast majority of the authors whose work was included aren't happy about it," he wrote. "Fixing the credits, nice as it may be, doesn't solve the issue of the whole package being illegal."

Smith was also accused of keeping the package under wraps until just before it was released and then contacting news sites in order to maximize publicity, a charge he denied. He claimed to have posted word about the project on Reddit "weeks ago" and had no hand in spreading the word to other sites. Not that it matters; Smith was asked (politely, for the record) to remove the collection and told that if he refused, Wordpress and any other site hosting the package would receive "DMCA and other applicable copyright takedown notices."

Smith said he was disappointed that he wasn't given a chance to correct the issues with the mod collection in some way that would make everyone happy, although whether or not that's even possible at this point looks rather doubtful. It would be nice if some accommodation could be reached, because the YouTube video promoting the collection pack looked mighty sweet. A discussion about the matter on the Morrowind forums was underway but appears to have been removed, so for now, we'll just have to sit back and see what happens next.

From The Escapist

To me, this brings up a lot of issues with the concept of modding and the desire to be completely and utterly recognised by a community that a lot of modders seem to have.

Both sides of this seem to have a point, though. If he didn't inform the modders, then he's being stupid. If the modders aren't willing to make a compromise for this absolutely amazing modpack, then they're dicks.

What do you all think?

( And does anyone have a download link for this? I have Morrowind sitting around somewhere... )

[jnecros]

Dude seriously..chill with making new topics...you seem like you bring chops to the table, but flooding the forums here is not going to do you any favors

[Googolplexed]

I have to agree.

Its not even like you have anything to do with it, or even have a major opinion on the topic other then "I'm not sure"

This is just, "What do you think"

Please just stop it.

[Xotes]

I don't really see the problem here. DEM made a topic with an informative post copied over, informing us as to the situation with this mod pack getting pulverized by a bunch of modders. It doesn't have any bearing on this specific topic that he's apparently (I say this because I can't be bothered to actually check) been going around making a bunch of different threads.

Also, don't most of us not have anything personal connected with (although opinions are often held, yes) the various news posts that get posted on the forum?

[Pillow_Killer]

Good thing I downloaded it. THere are also numerous torrents of the thing you can seed.

[Ioric Kittencuddler]

I pretty much just agree with DEM.  Don't see what the problem with making new threads about new topics is.

[Googolplexed]

Yeah, but generally there is something important or different about it
EG, you just found a good game, or something.

This is mostly just doing what's been happening all week, posting stuff that... isn't particularly noteworthy, and he doesn't have an opinion on
I don't think anyone here really cares

(Its not about making new threads, its just that Toady had to lock the past 7 he made in TWO days, its a bit beyond just simple thread making)

[Ioric Kittencuddler]

Well I can't say I noticed before, but looking at page two I see what you mean.