OK I only found two questions. If I missed any please point them out for me.
Argembarger: Too lurky. Who are your top picks? If you were scum, who would you have killed last night and why?
God I hate falling behind in mafia games and having to catch up again. It's really hard because everyone's already laid out all these arguments and such; it's hard to have a nice, original thought or two.
And I can't necessarily trust anyone's arguments because they could be scum.
Urg, must fight laziness, must do own work...
OK, here's what I think.
I actually really don't like what I see from both
Jokerman and
NativeForeigner.
I shall extend their cases directly from my last read on them, where I said,
Jokerman-EXE. As much as I want to avoid bringing Zath's death into this, I can't help but feel that you killed him because he had you pinned as scum and that made you uncomfortable. Finger of suspicion for now. Moooostly because I find it very strange that you just sort of say, very matter-of-factly, that you killed Zath, that you regret nothing, and then you leave that little tidbit there and move on to other things (which you may or may not be being attacked for by others at the moment). I don't entirely see how it's justified, I mean, you couldn't have known he was a SK, and any real reason you may have had to suspect him for being scum before his flip sounds OMGUSy to me. But, um, thanks for killing a serial killer? I guess?
I don't want to lay out the impression that I'm clinging to Zathras' tunnel against him mindlessly... just that that whole debacle is pretty irrevocably planted in my head, and asking me to totally ignore it is something I'm not prepared to do.
But now it looks like Joker and Native are OMGUSing each other >:-|
[...]
NativeForeigner. As I said in the Jokerman post, looks like Joker and Native are OMGUSing each other to me, which I would find hilarious, if they weren't focusing exclusively on each other. However, there seems to be some kind of odd thing going on between him and Toaster... A couple of times, it looks like Toaster is pushing Native, and getting him to attack Joker more. I could just be paranoid. And it's a pretty unsubstantial thing to attack someone for, but I'm gonna keep an eye on that. However,
Native, what's your read on Toaster?
Since Day 2 started, they seem to just be doing more of the same, focusing on each other. (-) on both of them.
NativeForeigner appears to be scumhunting though; (+) for him.
Jokerman handled Native and Zathras' questions pretty well, at least in my opinion; (+) for him.
So they're pretty even. So I shall question them! Huzzah!
NativeForeigner,
Your unvote of Zathras here is sending me confusing mixed messages. It looks like you're unvoting him because he attacked Joker. At the very least, your initial vote of Zathras kind of looked halfhearted. You even freely admit, later, that you think Zath's willingness to be blocked could be a ruse. Which is it? And why do you instead choose to IGNORE Zathras in favor of attacking Joker? The two activities can be done simultaneously, you know.
Jokerman,
Native was at least kind enough to share with everyone his reads/suspicions on everyone besides you. I'd like to see you follow suit.
On
Zathras, I don't really trust your sudden revival... Unfortunately, it's just something that will have to be confirmed/denied later on. Until that happens, you've been like a laser-guided Jokerman missile. Your case against him is very interesting,
"If Zath says he's found scum chances are he's found scum"
but what are your reads on everyone else? (link me if I simply overlooked them somewhere)
For the second question:
If I were scum, I would have wanted to kill Toaster last night. He reads town to me right now and I think Toaster is very effective town.
Unrelated:
Org: Holy shit, words, voting, attempts at usefulness! woo
Argembarger: You've been quiet. What do you think of my roleclaim?
Um, honestly? I don't know what to think of your roleclaim. Ask me again tomorrow, when the haikus achieve results or something.
OH, except, the one thing I did want to ask. When you answered my question about your haikus earlier, namely that it had to be 5-7-5, I think what I was actually getting at was, can you just pull an arbitrary haiku out of anyone's post if you want? Like in this sentence, the words are arranged in five, seven and five. Well, it would have been, if I could have thought of a grammatically correct one-syllable word to shove in that final phrase. Could you have taken that sentence and called it a haiku for a roleblock? Because there's a good chance almost everyone has "accidentally" posted a haiku in that sense.