-SNIP-
Lemon: Why not send it now? You can change it before day end. Also, what do you expect to hear that could make you change your mind?
I already sent it, but i hadn't sent it before when jim asked me if i had. I expect to hear nothing that could change my mind, short of one of the sorcers revealing themselves and their powers, since i don't know what any of the sorcerers do yet, until i know (or have any suspicions about what a color does) then its pretty much random.
Why? You can't just vote someone without giving a reason.
Well, you can, but you can't expect to convince anyone that way.
My reason is that to me, his plan to tell people who to assist by pm's seem a bit scummy, BUT thats about it, i'm not really THAT suspicious of him, just him more then everyone else, because no one really seems that scummy to me yet (besides him a little bit).
And I asked you that question because I'm proving a point. You had to be prompted to send in your assist. This is the point of what I'm proposing.
Sigh, i would have send it in irregardless, you sending me a pm of who to vote for wouldn't change me voting.
Wait a second, I don't believe you came up with this on your own. Surprisingly relevant criticism to a plan in a unique mafia variant? And it sounds so familiar to criticism I leveled in the last game.
Yeah, I don't buy this for a second.
Unvote Criptfeind. Who's feeding you answers, lemon10? Oh, and while we're at it, why don't you describe how I even could figure out who the town sorcerers were.
I'm not quite stupid enough not to be able to come with anything on my own or come up with anything relevant, yeah i don't know the nuances of how mafia is played (eg. i suck at scumhunting and thinking up hypotheticals), but it seems to me that i should be able to think up things on my own. And no one is feeding me answers.
And i hadn't quite thought through how you could find it out, although i think you could, but ill do that now.
You could tell 1 person to vote for a sorcerer, and everyone else to vote for the other two, if the sorc doesn't get the vote and he said he sent one, its pretty obvious he's a sorcerer, if the sorc does get the vote, then you know that he isn't a sorc
If you tell 3 people to support each sorcerer, and sorc 1 got 2 votes, sorc 2 got 2 votes and sorc 3 got 3 votes, you would know that (unless people voted for people other then they said they would) that 2 of the people in group 1 are sorcs and 1 in group 2, while none in group 3. If your mafia knowing who to kill would be a great help (i assume)
So while it might not let you know for sure, it would help you figure it out greatly. And it is a bit rude to say that you don't think i am unable to think up things myself.
And yeah, the only harm is IF you are scum, but i don't think it would be that much help if you aren't.