Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Toaster]

Unvote Eduren.  Fair enough.

SS then?

HAve fun getting nightkilled.

You dopp or exterminator then? Only those wouldn't spread the spores.

SHAD0Wdump: This is an extremely weak attack- it really looks to me like thinly veiled deflection.  This, coupled with your attempts to antagonize people, just looks like an attempt to get people angry instead of a legitimate attempt to find scum.  Give some solid reasons for your vote, or get back out there and find some.

And YouTube links are not scum hunting.

[JanusTwoface]

Sorry, it's only my 2nd game, and I royally sucked in the RVS of the first one, so it's effectively my first experience with RVS.  Would you like me to rephrase the question?

You're being waaaay too nice. That's scummy. Even if you manage to get yourself lynched, please don't give up on Mafia. Learn and move on. That being said, if you want to survive Day 1, stop being scummy.

And a policy lynch doesn't make the day any shorter.

Not timewise, but it makes us short town.  Scum should be lynched, not town, no matter how stupid.  That is the point of town.
Unvote.
Vote JanusTwoface.

It only makes us short town if they're actually town. And even then, if they're dragging down the town it's a good trade. Mafias (in general) are balanced so that you can mislynch twice and still win.

That is a really bad way to go.
You are giving up. Really.
You have two days to convince us you aren't scum. Try.

Skim it. Read. You need to to understand what is happening.
Not reading is scummy.

Huh.  Actually being helpful.  Still not actively scumhunting and a bit short on the overall content, but it's a start.

unvote Org

Please continue to be helpful (and cut the herp derp crap).

Spoiler: Responses to Criptfeind (click to show/hide)

I'm not sure why... Your entire post is essentially worthless except the comment on webadict, but here goes.  Anything I didn't respond to, I didn't think was worth responding to.

I got a feeling that Janus is going to try to sneak away well you guys go after that turtle, but I don't think I will let him.JTF

Umm... what?  What exactly do you mean sneak away? I'm not going anywhere.

More useful then you so far. He has called someone on somthing scummy, all you have done is beat your chest about a policy lynch.

If all you've seen me do is that, you haven't been reading well.

How? Randomly lynching people has no way to work ever, I am sure even you know that, what do you think we should do?

Thanks for taking that out of context. I already answered this literally sentences after the quote you pulled out.

DON'T WORRY WE DON'T HAVE TO BE GOOD! SOMETHING ELSE WILL SAVE US!

Nope.  What I meant is that almost everyone has a power role. Thus I personally have a backup plan.

But it sure as hell shuts down conversation. Hell, if we had agreed with you the game would pretty much start on day two.

The whole point is that people don't agree with me. And the it doesn't shut down conversation. I'm doing it and people are talking about it. How hard is that to understand?

For the record, your only non scummy post was the in post. Nice one JTF.

Bullshit.

Usefulness comes later.

This should be enough to lynch you on.

SS=Town

Wrong. SS == 3rd party. Deal with the scum first.

, I am not a gambling man

So far you are.

How? Also less Org please, more smart.

No. Less is more.

Wrong. Minimalism actively hurts town. Even if you refuse to read through what's already been said, at the very least you need to be active from here on out.

[Jim Groovester]

SHAD0Wdump: This is an extremely weak attack- it really looks to me like thinly veiled deflection.  This, coupled with your attempts to antagonize people, just looks like an attempt to get people angry instead of a legitimate attempt to find scum.  Give some solid reasons for your vote, or get back out there and find some.

So you don't buy his Spore Spreader claim?

[SHAD0Wdump]

Fine.

He suggests me getting nightkilled, but only exterminators and dopps can do that without just spreading the spores around. SS hurts town by sapping abilities. So why would Dopps or Exterminator want to kill a SS?

I had a sense this was an attempt to hide a potential kill on me with inoccence, but the fact is no method by town to kill a SS will work to their advantage, and the same is true for dopps and exterminator for a differant reason.

The most that can be done is for town to try to get dopps or exterminater to screw up and hit the SS.

Back to three for me, zoop!

[Toaster]

He's being way too obvious about it.  It looks to me like he's trying to make everyone think he's a spore spreader.

Post edit warning:  You get credit for explaining your vote, but your reasoning is still very thin.  Do you still think he's scum?  If not, who do you think is?

[SHAD0Wdump]

Well, two reasons I feel scumminess from the guy...

A: He's attempting to get me lynched by assuming spore spreader. Lynching a spore spreader is probably the worst thing you can do to one.

B: He switched his reasoning to me not being a spore spreader. While I'll stress this is true, it brings less reason to the table for my lynch as I'm not trying to claim spore spreader.


Ok, the three thing is heavily hypocritical now, I'm just trying a playstyle that I feel is fun. Plus it is good for attempting to antagonize people.

Blahahaha.

[Criptfeind]

Well, two reasons I feel scumminess from the guy...

A: He's attempting to get me lynched by assuming spore spreader. Lynching a spore spreader is probably the worst thing you can do to one.

B: He switched his reasoning to me not being a spore spreader. While I'll stress this is true, it brings less reason to the table for my lynch as I'm not trying to claim spore spreader.


Ok, the three thing is heavily hypocritical now, I'm just trying a playstyle that I feel is fun. Plus it is good for attempting to antagonize people.

Blahahaha.

Who is this guy you are talking of here? Also trolling is not the same as mafia playing.

Fuck this, I am going to my good computer.

[SHAD0Wdump]

Also trolling is not the same as mafia playing.

Yeah it is, Web does it all the time.

[Mysteriousbluepuppet]

Also trolling is not the same as mafia playing.

Yeah it is, Web does it all the time.

You don't have to be like Webadict. This be wholly unnapropriate.

In other news, i find that Kamina really need to get a grip, that towel was dropped way too fast. Hell, the game is started for less thna 12 hours and seems you are already ready to die. Wanna survive ? Get scumhunting

[SHAD0Wdump]

Get scumhunting

Already found one.

Anyway, busy streaming.

[Mysteriousbluepuppet]

Get scumhunting

Already found one.

Anyway, busy streaming.

Oh actually i was talking to Kamina, sorry if i was not clear.

[Mysteriousbluepuppet]

About the scumhinting, not the webadict-ness

Hell i need some sleep.

[JanusTwoface]

A: He's attempting to get me lynched by assuming spore spreader. Lynching a spore spreader is probably the worst thing you can do to one.

You countered this point with the second sentence. If he's trying to lynch you, he either doesn't think you're the spore or he's a third party. It's as easy as that.

B: He switched his reasoning to me not being a spore spreader. While I'll stress this is true, it brings less reason to the table for my lynch as I'm not trying to claim spore spreader.

Saying things doesn't make them true. And outright claiming the spore spreader would be a rather poor plan. WIFOMing it like you're doing is a little better, but it essentially means you are one of three things:
- Town working against the town, lynchable
- WIFOMing Spore Spreader, lynchable anyways (see below)
- Scum trying to hide behind being spore spreader, lynchable

For Spore Spreader prime, getting lynched makes sense and it doesn't necessarily hurt the town too badly. We lose 0-2 power roles, depending on how many aliens/dopps were voting you. If the dice fall badly and both of your spore clouds land on dopps/aliens, you lose.

In any case if there's a Xenozooligist about, I bet they'll kidnap you tonight. Good chance that you're not townie, so a good pick either way.

Also trolling is not the same as mafia playing.

Yeah it is, Web does it all the time.

Please don't emulate webadict. One is already far more than we need.

[KaminaSquirtle]

Sorry, it's only my 2nd game, and I royally sucked in the RVS of the first one, so it's effectively my first experience with RVS.  Would you like me to rephrase the question?

You're being waaaay too nice. That's scummy. Even if you manage to get yourself lynched, please don't give up on Mafia. Learn and move on. That being said, if you want to survive Day 1, stop being scummy.

I understand this now.  Somehow this was never pointed out in the BM.  Useless thing.

And a policy lynch doesn't make the day any shorter.

Not timewise, but it makes us short town.  Scum should be lynched, not town, no matter how stupid.  That is the point of town.
Unvote.
Vote JanusTwoface.

It only makes us short town if they're actually town. And even then, if they're dragging down the town it's a good trade. Mafias (in general) are balanced so that you can mislynch twice and still win.

Are you really saying we should mislynch less than ideal townies over scum because it won't absolutely kill us?  That's complete bullshit.  We shouldn't settle for townies when we can find scum.

, I am not a gambling man

So far you are.

How? Also less Org please, more smart.

No. Less is more.

Wrong. Minimalism actively hurts town. Even if you refuse to read through what's already been said, at the very least you need to be active from here on out.

I agree with this at least.


Shadow, you're obviously trying to get yourself lynched.  You can't really be that stupid.

He's being way too obvious about it.  It looks to me like he's trying to make everyone think he's a spore spreader.

WIFOM, but still a validish point.

Also trolling is not the same as mafia playing.

Yeah it is, Web does it all the time.

Case in point.

In other news, i find that Kamina really need to get a grip, that towel was dropped way too fast. Hell, the game is started for less thna 12 hours and seems you are already ready to die. Wanna survive ? Get scumhunting

I'm trying to get a feel for how these games work.  I figured it a good idea to cool off and think more logically for a bit.

[SHAD0Wdump]

You can't really be that stupid.

I rarely play mafia, yes I can.