You originally suspected me because Criptfeind was buddying up to me. Don't misrepresent the facts. Whatever your reptilian brain said about me and the fucking goddamn plan came after you concluded that Criptfeind, being the scum that he was, was buddying up to me. Funny how that turned out.
Your memory is at fault. I denounced your plan as scummy even before you formally proposed it
[1]. Then Criptfeind
agreed with your scummy plan, which I considered buddying, plus he dropped other scumtells, so I voted him
[2]. Then he backed down, and you insisted on it even in the face of evidence, so I voted you
[3]. I voted him at the end of day because it was the only scummy-person lynch possible (voting you would result in a no-lynch)
[4]. It was always about the anti-town plan. The time I was voting him was for going along with it, plus his other scumtells.
And about the fucking goddamn plan you've got your panties in a bunch about: there was no point talking about it today because there's no further advantage to be gained from organizing the support. The scum school cannot be conclusively determined with only two schools and five apprentices remaining.
You said yesterday that there would be a point, regardless: "investigatory benefits"
[5]. Do you say now that there were none? Because there clearly were, just not the ones you hoped. Plus you didn't just "not talk about it", you failed to even answer a simple question: did you support red yesterday, as you said you would? It's kinda important, ain't it? Did you?
About your second point: the scum school cannot be
conclusively determined, but a very good educated guess can be made based on who chose what colours, their stated reasons to do so, and subsequent behaviour.
I'm OK with the idea that "one of Jim and Zathras is scum"; so if the rest of you guys think I'm full of shit, vote me and support Red. If you don't, vote him and support White.
BAD IDEA.
Proposing an either/or lynch at lylo (and in general) is a terrific way to lose games. It focuses the game on two individuals and easily lets the scum blend into the background.
I agree it's not the best idea, but it's the best one I have at the moment, so I go with it. I think your plan, your attitude about it, your colour selection, and your actions since are scummy enough to vote the shit out of you. If others agree, let's hang you. If they think I'm scum lying, then let them hang me. We'll discuss it further in either case (day ends 4 RL days from now, plenty of time to hash it out). But I'm explicitly not binding the discussion to those two options, as I ask for alternatives, and I even propose another one below that you take the time to shit on as well.
...or I'm OK with other ideas as far as securing a scum lynch today. I'll support a lynch of Org if the rest of you guys think he's scum. Unfortunately, of the rest, I'm not getting enough of a reading to be ready to vote them just yet.
Now this is interesting.
So you only support an Org lynch if everybody else feels up to it? A mercenary attitude to your vote like this is incredibly suspicious.
Why are you making the condition of your vote if everybody else thinks he's scum? What do you think? It's incredibly scummy to say you're not sure about Org but also to support his lynch.
Duh. I support his lynch if others do because I can't hang him with just my vote. Obvious. I'm OK with him hanging, and if enough others are as well, I'll move my vote from you to him. Otherwise it stays on you. I'm not as sure about his scummitude as I am of yours, but close enough to support a lynch, sure; especially since others would provide reasons when they vote, with which I may agree (if I don't, the plan changes), or I may have missed.
There's three scum out there. I think I've been able to smoke out only one (you), and get smells of scum from another (Org). Whoever has most support at end of day will hang, and my vote will be on one of these two... unless someone else comes and becomes even scummier -- I'm pretty sure at least one of Eduren, IronyOwl & Person is scum, but I don't know which (since almost half the players are scum by now, it's not a particularly adventurous guess, but there you go).
I can't hang anyone on my vote alone, so consensus must be built. My scum list has two items on it for now, and I'll vote for whoever is most productive to vote at day end. That's as it should be, yes?