Dang. The moral system in RDR2 is a bit off eh?
A bit, aye. I've been a goody-goody the whole game (up until a certain psychological break I experienced after getting so damn fed up with the wanted system, which is its own entire post's worth of ranting), helping people and saving lives all over the place, but that's never what people remember.
People remember the time that fellow punched me in the bar because I'd apparently looked at him for too long (or hadn't looked at him for long enough), and I responded by punching the next person down the bar from me because the melee controls are a bit wonky. When someone else throws a fist, it's a good ol' brawl and fine entertainment. When I throw a fist, it's a crime and crime is wrong. Crime is also cause for panic.
Weeks later, and passing through the streets I'll still get people saying "We don't need your kind of trouble around here!", "Haven't you caused enough harm?", "Just stay away from me", but nobody mentions "Oh hey, there's the fellow who saved my cousin from certain death TWICE, donated the equivalent of $1500 to a homeless shelter, has cuddled half the dogs in the entire city, and also freed that one officer when he was about to be executed as a political prisoner".
To be fair though, trouble really does follow Arthur everywhere he goes. The NPCs can't get up to
this kind of shit on their own.
Oh, right, there's also the honor system, which tracks your "good deeds" vs. "bad deeds", much like the original. Like the original, there are special buffs/effects for reaching milestones on either the good or bad honor sides of the bar, except in RDR2 you only get buffs on the good side. The bad side gets... Well... Your life gets a lot easier by not worrying about the
god damn honor system anymore.
Killing lawmen is bad for your honor, as is killing, robbing, and even insulting innocent civilians. Thankfully bounty hunters don't count as Lawful Good lawmen, so you don't get a hit to your honor for killing them. Unfortunately, bounty hunters bring dogs to track you down, and the dogs will also attack you with their instakill animations. And dogs, being the goodest boys, will always cause your honor to drop if you dare to fight back against them.