I honestly didn't expect a masterpiece. I guess I've been spoiled on Marvel, but I wasn't even expecting a good Marvel entry, I just expected Captain America I.
I like humanity in my characters, and there was no point for Wonder Woman when she was remotely human. She was just superman with breasts.
Bah, I'll drop it here. I hate wasted potential.
I think the main thing is that, regardless of objective cinematic quality, it hit a very deep cord with pretty much every woman I know that saw it. They could nitpick the hell out of it, but they don't bother because most of them have been waiting for a movie like that their entire lives.
Doesn't matter if it was amazingly executed, it matters that it exists. I'm pretty sure a lot of the reviews are people trying to justify that feeling.
Personally, I thought it was a lot of fun and it exceeded my rather low expectations of a DC film.
Which is fair enough, but it's important to recognize the difference between liking a movie for personal reasons vs. liking it because it's a good movie, at least as far as reviews go.
WW fell afoul of the biggest tripping point of DC: WW, Supes', &c. nature as Mary Sues when handled by bad writers. The really bad DC writers handle those effectively invincible characters like this, forcing them to job or act like OOC grimderps to create a transparently false tension. The sorta bad ones use shitty plot devices (Huzzah! Beige kryptonite!) to do end-runs around their invulnerability and maybe let someone else play a meaningful role in the story. The decent ones pit them against equally overpowered enemies so that the conflict isn't as much about them as it is about the people they're protecting.
The
good ones write for the DC animated series. And every crappy DC film just further reminds us of how good those were. Easily the best portrayals of most of the DC lineup.
Note how Marvel doesn't have this issue. A very big chunk of that stems from all of their heroes and heroines being much closer to human, genuine people with varied strengths, weaknesses, and beliefs, rather than invulnerable moral paragons.