Incase Webaddict didn't see it:
I usually (99% of the time.) get on at 3:30 Eastern standard time (GMT -5), do my posting for about half an hour to an hour, and then move on to other things.
And before you ask, that is the only time I can spend on the Internet.
Eclipsetail would be my vote for one of the scum. He's barely posted, lurked, and never seems to even try to explain his actions. I'll bet he'll bandwagon on whoever Webaddict votes for.
If I voted for scum, and he was scum, why would he bandwagon on my target? That doesn't make a whole lot of sense, now does it?
I assume you already know the answer.
If you didn't vote for scum, he would vote for that person (assuming he is scum.) If you voted for, say BroodyMoods, he would bangwagon onto him. If you voted his scum partner, he wouldn't vote for him. It just looks like to me that he would bangwagon with what appears to be the most experienced player in the game, as long as the vote suited his needs (ie not his scum partner). I doubt he would be that stupid.
USEC_OFFICER - Everything you post isn't really anything that is helpful. You were doing well on Day 1, but you've gotten a lacklusterful Day 2 start. Heck, I'm no longer sure if I can put you above BroodyMoods with what he did, but I kinda have to, just because of you really don't have anything to contribute. You're just bandwagoning on eclipsetail here, and I pointed out a flaw in your argument which you have yet to respond to, but I'm still open to see more from you.
Can I first say, I'm doing way better than my second game.
Right, now with that out of the way...
So, being the fourth person to say that eclipsetail is scummy is bandwagoning, but being the last person to say it isn't?
Here's a list of people, from scummy, to least scummy:
eclipsetail
Scatterbrain
USEC_OFFICER
TheBroodyMoods
breadbocks
Zako
Webadict
(Snipped, for easier reading.)
Because seeing that you placed him at the top of your list, after everybody else has posted, looks like bandwagoning.
I assume that your answer will involve saying that you always suspected him, or that he really should be lynched. Well, what prevents me from sayin the same thing? If I think eclipsetail is the scummiest and should be lynched, then I should be able to say that, no matter what people have said before me!
I'll try to contribute more (doubt you'll like it much.)
Now, for my list of scummy players, which I promised everybody I would post today:
Eclipse: I posted my reasons before, but I'll also add that he has not been answering any questions directed at him. (Like one I asked you)
Eclipsetail, what made you oppose extention without posting a reason? And why did you not post for two whole days before that?
Even if Eclipse is town, with the way he's been acting, it would hurt the town to keep him alive to day three, unless we manage to lynch one of the scum today, then he would be dangerous on day four. Eclipse looks (and has been acting like) a person that the scum could easily manipulate. As long as the scum can keep him voting on the same person, they have the game in the bag.
Breadbocks would be my next choice for the second most scummiest. He's been acting like an idiot, but I'm not 100% percent sure that he's only a noob or a noob who happens to be scum. If Eclipse happens to be scum, then I doubt Breadbocks would be his scum partner (And the otherway around), seeing as Shibdib was nightkilled. If they were scum together, I would imagine that either Zako or BroodyMoods would have been nightkilled instead (As it seems more like a noobish NK than Shibdib, which I would assoiate with their characters.)
Webaddict, you be my third choice for most scummiest. There are two reasons why I placed you third on my list.
First, Spartan's response to Zathras on page seven (You can't miss it, it's the only one he posted:)
I'm not lurking, and I've been picking up tells.
What exactly are you trying to pull here Zathras? I know you're up to something!
He says he's not lurking, but picking up scumtells, which sends warning signals to me as a terrible response, one that should have looked to him as a terrible response too. Of course, you can't account for Spartan's responses, so my second reason is this:
Scatterbrain, I would say webadict could be hesitant to answer because of him getting Spartan's scum roll, but then why would Spartan have left if he'd gotten a scum roll? If I had to take a shot at why he left, it would be because he got townie, so left out of disappointment.
Well, I don't want people to bandwagon behind me in case I'm wrong. It's unlikely that I'm wrong, but I don't want to have to dig through sheep-followers after I say who it is I think is scum. After I have some answers (You need one too, pal), I'll divulge my secrets.
And, unfortunately, I am not scum. I told Vector to make a scum drop out, but she just wouldn't allow for such. Perhaps next time, I can school some newbies, but not this time.
Ther bottom part of the post caught my eye. Seems out of place to me. Strikes me as scummy. So I'm going with my gut and placing you at third.
BroodyMoods, Zako and Scatterbrain have not really drawn my attention in any way, though I would not rule out the possiblity of the scum being any of them.
Now if you exuse me, I'm done typing for an hour and thirty minutes, and shall instead play majesty.