Big enough for ya?
BreadBocks, for reasons of last round.
Lol @ this. If ever I saw a newbie scum, this is it. I was hoping for some more information out of him, but given his... other statements... I'll assume that he doesn't plan to say anything else.
EDIT: Yeeeeah... so, we're going to have to lynch him.
Afternoon, all. Sorry about missing two pages. I went asleep about half an hour before night ended. Only got the chance to catch up now. Seems I missed quite a bit.
Broody, I think the reason shibdib was lynched because they couldn't take the chance that a doctor would protect the important scumhunter, so they killed a town-sider who was of no notice whose vote could hammer a scum.
Zako, see above. The town mistakenly lynched a townie with a lust for my blood, and the scum took advantage of the confusion.
Webadict, welcome to the game!
USEC, going back a page to where you questioned Broody about why he didn't check for eclipse's vote, I think he was aware, which was why he thought he'd regret the vote.
Scatterbrain, I would say webadict could be hesitant to answer because of him getting Spartan's scum roll, but then why would Spartan have left if he'd gotten a scum roll? If I had to take a shot at why he left, it would be because he got townie, so left out of disappointment.
Eclipse, why are you lurking? Major Middle Finger of Suspicion here.
Diablous, so I don't end up half a day late like this again, what is the time cap for nights?
See, I don't really like you either. For this reason:
Ah. Well, As I said earlier, eclipse is seeming scummy, but I could identify with noob syndrome. As for main picks, still need to choose between eclipse and you, webadict for most scummy. Welcome to the game, indeed.
It's the fact you have yet to give any hint as to what you know that seems to me as scummy.
Okay, that's why I'm scummy. Now how about the other?
Eclipetail has been
1)Lurking to an extreme
2)Acting scummy (Opposing extension with out even a meager excuse)
3)Seeing as how Zathras flipped townie, I'm willing to believe him on his advice of scummyness.
See, it's this reasoning that gets you third on my list. You're RIGHT, but you're only half-right, which is how (better) scum tend to operate. You'd have to be bussing your own partner, but you're focusing too much on actual scum to find a fake person to incriminate, so you just throw out the guy who's pressuring you with whatever reason you can possibly make up.
You also assumed that talking about the BBB Gambit was a good idea. It's not, no matter what alignment you are.
Just realized that I misread the post. Breadbock was still going to be lynched at that time. Sorry everybody.
Eclipsetail would be my vote for one of the scum. He's barely posted, lurked, and never seems to even try to explain his actions. I'll bet he'll bandwagon on whoever Webaddict votes for.
Nobody else seems to leap out at me with scumminess at the moment, give me till tomorrow and I'll find something about everyone else.
See, I was really hoping you'd have two suspects. You'd better start finding things about people, because you can't just sit back. You need to participate more in this game. Like, NOW. Because I saw lots of posts Yesterday, and you're not going to just sit there and let posts rain in without making some of them.
Now, who else has yet to answer, besides me?
I'd like to try and make a more concise list, thank you very much. List most scummy to least.
Eclipsetail : for obvious reasons; Lurking, Bandwagoning previous day, Opposing day extension, lack of explanations, generally all around scummy attitude.
breadbocks: same reasons as before. His posts are light, and while not nearly as bad as Eclipsetail's, he seems to leave a lot of room for wiggling. He also tends to vote first and explain later.
Zako: Support the lynch of Zathras and was the one who really drove the point home. I have doubts about his townie-hood. Seems remorseful about the innocent lynch, but having lead it to spare breadbocks, despite insisting that he thought Zathras was scum, I can't help but wonder if he was saving a scum buddy or just a good draw for town's attentions later.
Webaddict: No offense, you're a good player. You're making folks jump through hoops, which could be your veteran way of teaching/hazing/humoring us. If you were scum you'd tear us apart. You've taken over for a player who hadn't posted a single thing- damning or otherwise. I have no reason to really trust you, which is why I have every reason thus far to suspect you. Points, however, for trying to draw people into the game for your parlor scene.
I have some reservations about the rest, but these are the top four suspects- and the top two being who I see as scum team at the moment (or at least highest on the terrorist watch list).
I like you. Very creative answer. Wrong on a lot of points, but still, nice answer. Yeah, eclipsetail is more than likely scum and breadbocks is a good third choice, but why Zako or me and not scatteredbrain?
Problem is, you're not looking at everyone. You're looking at only the people that are talking, which doesn't include scatteredbrain, who is lurking hardcore. It's just a short-sightedness I'd like to make sure you correct. And, just so you know that this is more of an IC comment and not one to deflect away from myself, it's okay to be suspicious of the talking people. It's just not okay to NOT be suspicious of the quiet ones.
EDIT: You're also DEAD WRONG ON THE ZATHRAS LYNCH. See, YOU were the one that lynched Zathras, and pinning the blame on someone else? That's just downright scumtacular of you. See, I didn't notice that until I went searching, but that's exactly what you did. YOU lynched him. Zako threw out evidence on him. Just for that, I had to boost you up on my list, you lying sack of crap.
Just so everyone is aware, here's his post:
I'll likely regret this, but I have to go with my gut:
unvote
Zathras, I sincerely hope I am not wrong about this.
He basically lynched Zathras by himself. I wouldn't mind that if he wasn't a man and stuck by it, but he just lost a whole ton of points in that one line.
DOUBLE EDIT: Also, your scumlist looks a little familiar...
For the record, before the day ends, I agree with you on eclipsetail. If I do hang, when I flip town, go after him even above breadbox. He bandwagoned on both of us, and seems happy to see anyone hang. If this is the case, the other one is probably Zako, since went after me safely knowing that breadbox is a townie because he knows who the scum is, and made no attempt whatsoever of going after eclipse.
Oh right, it's the list of that guy who you lynched, with a little twist at the end. Well, almost. The breadbocks thing isn't his, but breadbocks was the person you were voting previously.
Sorry, uni demanded my time again and I was on a train most of the day.
Welcome to the game Webby! Glad to see Spartan replaced, but being all mysterious isn't really helping. Tell us what you think.
As for who I think is scum, here's what I think right now, in decending order of scummitude:
Eclipsetail, you haven't told us your reasons for any of your actions. You basically said for every explaination, 'Wut he sed.' repeatedly throughout the game. We want your PERSONAL opinion about scum, not someone elses. Talk to us man, don't be afraid to say your thing! Fear is for scum!
I have an odd feeling about scatterbrain right now. Call it a gut feeling, but I want to know what he thinks of breadbocks' statements and the overall town position.
USEC, Broody, Breadbocks and Webadict I don't think are scum right now. USEC gives off town tells to me, Broody looks and sounds towny, Breadbocks is an idiot for voting himself and I have no idea about you Webby.
So, tell me gentlemen:
Webadict, who do YOU think are scum, and why? Don't hide behind your superior thinking. Tell us townies your opinion, it may not be necessarily correct after all.
Scatterbrain, why should I believe you are town? You seem to be fading nicely into the background. Step into the spotlight buddy, show your colors!
This guy... This guy.
Nailed on the head. I've been calling scatteredbrain and eclipsetail the entire game. Why Zathras got lynched yesterday... I have no clue! He threw out no scumtells, you let people who weren't contributing lurk, and worst of all you left breadbocks alive.
EDIT: Well, maybe I was wrong. I found a lot more than I was looking for when I went back. Ill need to keep thinking about it.
But, that's not really my problem. That's a problem with you guys.
EDIT: Upon re-reading, USEC actually jumped to the third spot. Breadbocks is scummy in his way, but USEC is scummy in regular ways.
Here's a list of people, from scummy, to least scummy:
eclipsetail - Seriously, what are you doing? You end the day and can't be bothered to post a statement to fix that? Every other post from you just seems to be like the lamest excuse for why you did something. And it's always excuses! Are you too busy, or are you just smashing your face into the keyboard and making sentences? If you're blind, hey, I understand, but you need to take the game seriously and LOOK AT WHAT PEOPLE ARE DOING! I could not be anymore angry with you or your playstyle than I am now, especially if you're Town.
Scatterbrain - You... I can't decide, quite honestly. At some points, you actually seem exemplary as town. You make a couple Wall of Texts, which is a good thing, but my problem is that you're lurking and that you've only had one real focus the entire game: eclipsetail. Which would be easy to do if you were scum, as you could put minimal pressure on him while knowing he's scum, and hence making your argument look pretty real, while on the side not having to participate with the actual lynches.
USEC_OFFICER - Everything you post isn't really anything that is helpful. You were doing well on Day 1, but you've gotten a lacklusterful Day 2 start. Heck, I'm no longer sure if I can put you above BroodyMoods with what he did, but I kinda have to, just because of you really don't have anything to contribute. You're just bandwagoning on eclipsetail here, and I pointed out a flaw in your argument which you have yet to respond to, but I'm still open to see more from you.
TheBroodyMoods - See, I'd rather you had gotten breadbocks lynched yesterday, but then I realized that you really only had two options to choose from: Zathras or breadbocks, with an inability to get an Extension out of Zathras or anyone else for that matter. Basically meaning you were really stuck on who to choose, now weren't you? EDIT: Unless, of course, you plan on deflecting that entire lynch on Zathras. That officially boosted you to fourth, up from sixth. I'd put you in third, but I don't have enough evidence on you to make a good case. You also just sort of sheepfollowed Zathras's last will.
breadbocks - See, I couldn't put you AND USEC in the third spot, but I had to put you two somewhere. You... just generally... do stupid things. Things that don't work. I'm going to assume you think you're funny though, as opposed to scum, because you're a newbie and I realize that you would have been hit really, REALLY hard by your scum IC for doing that. So, I just moved you higher than USEC, who seems to love the list-making process.
Zako - You, I have no problem with. At the beginning of the game, you attempted to stop breadbocks from making himself a target, and that lead to your attack on Zathras, who was attacking breadbocks which you were supposing was town. In fact, you've been trying to round up the most activity throughout the thread, that I couldn't possibly let you get lynched unless a Role Cop inspected you and got Godfather or something. It's not buddying: It's a sign that you're either really good Scum, or really good Town.
Webadict - I have only just gotten into the game, and while my previous incarnation was a lurker, I will not be. My goal is to make sure that you guys are talking EVERY MINUTE OF EVERY DAY. If you haven't posted anything about anyone as of yet, you will be hounded by me. That means you, Scatterbrain! I don't care if it's to point out flaws, to add to arguments, to justify your vote, or if it's to obtain evidence,
YOU. WILL. TALK!If you do not talk, I will have to assume the worst about you.
Generally, I hate lists, but this allows me to view multiple people at once, seeing as how, looking back, it's possible I might be wrong.