Imploring Org to give explanations for his actions and work more closely with the town is simply a loosely veiled request that he reveal his strategy. Given his declaration that revealing his strategy would reveal his role, which you were explicitly responding to, this equates to your asking him to reveal his role.
You're rolefishing.
Only scum would be rolefishing D1, since the secrecy of their roles is one of the few advantages town has.
You are either scum or you don't quite grasp role strategy in mafia, in which case being lynched will teach you not to rolefish without a solid reason next time.
Wow, really? You are actually, honestly trying to say that what I said is blatantly wrong, and explaining what you're doing
automatically reveals your role? Goddamn, if I'd known that I wouldn't have responded to your questions as to why I was rolefishing!
Now you know my role!Unvote, Vote Lonewolf I. No townie is going to accept "can't say, go away" as a response unless they're certain someone's town, which would take some incredible readings on Org at this point.
Mr. Person, you put my name instead of Lonewolf's twice, why was that? It would be crazy to say so out loud, but could it be a Freudian slip, since you were trying to draw attention away from Lonewolf and onto me?
IronyOwl: Fair enough, but I'm curious about one thing (and this is not directed at Org, but is rhetorical). What the heck kind of role defines your strategy in such a way as giving out your strategy would reveal your role? I think we know generally enough about the roles in this game to show that there aren't any like that. Maybe in a Ridiculous Mafia or something, but not here. Regardless of your role, your prime directive is to hunt scum.
Ask Lonewolf.
If my strategy is to be purposefully obnoxious to see who doesn't do anything about it, is it not hunting scum?
Generally, scum will be less likely to go after me. Sure, maybe a stab here and there, but whats the point? He hurts town more when he is town?
Obviously, those who attack and then back off are probably scum.
Oh mah gawd I am so devious.
Too predictable, Org. Plus, unpredictable results. Not everyone is going to hammer you, if only because they've given up on you being useful or are busy with other things, and some scum might push you to scumhunt in order to look townish. After all, if they don't think you're useful, why worry about you trying to scumhunt?
The rest, I'm not exactly seeing a lot to work with.
Then make some to work with. I believe both major discussions resulted from Org's random question and questioning of said question. Which is partially just Org, but still. You can't wait for things to get done, you have to do them yourself.
Solifuge, what the hell?
I'm making a point of stating that I will not be participating in the present shenanigans. Take this as you will.
Unless I'm mistaken, this is your last post,
and your second post in the game. You say you're not going to "participate in the present shenanigans" without explaining what that means, then lurk until day 2? Are you actually going to play or not? Even Org is
posting, regardless of how useful it is.
Author
Topic: Supernatural Mafia - Round 2 - Game over! (Read 71082 times)