I am really thrilled by both the massive participation here in zagibu's thread, and the response we've gotten from Toady (IE the mass build tool, slated improvements ala Underground Diversity) and have been thinking about ways we could improve the system for the next run.
One little thing I was thinking about is how the concepts/comments around the suggestions are scattered across the threads and the 10 pages of this one. Having single consolidated threads for the topics would make it much more organized and easier for Toady to read through. It would also help to cut down on duplicate/repetitive threads (this has been a huge benefit of this thread).
My suggestion is this:
(If and) when the next "brainstorming" occurs, the initial suggestion could be accompanied by a link to a topic discussion thread where the idea, ramifications, synergies, limitations, etc could be discussed. This would also help with informing potential poll takers of just what is meant by a vague one liner. The poll administrator could then add the link into the initial post for reference.
IE:
Top 10 Round Two ideas:
Nobles should wear pajamas ( URL to pajama thread )
Kittens should ambush butchers (URL to kitten ambush thread)
Stones should spontaneously explode ( URL to exploding stone thread )
The suggestion should only include a link to its own thread if:
- The suggestion is complex, has many details or options needing discussion (IE stop the No Dwarves Outside entrance dance did NOT need one)
- You are the original suggester, the idea is common, or the originator has given you permission to run the thread
- You intend to check on, discuss and update the OP of the new thread as the discussion evolves
As an example, let me offer up my own current thread: (not an advert)
http://www.bay12games.com/forum/index.php?topic=22024.0Notice I have (as of today) modified the original suggestion twice as people have pointed out ways it could be improved.
edit: working one one such thread for Underground Diversity but don't want to post it yet until I have done enough back research to make it useful.