Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

who will

0 (0%)

win

0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Voting closed: July 09, 2010, 08:17:28 pm

[ein]

I've fallen in love with the Urumis myself, since I saw them in the comic requiem.

So that's what they're called.
Those things are awesome.
Kalaripayatu (a martial art that uses them) also uses sashes as defensive weapons.

[CJ1145]

If we're going by how cool someone's sword is, Bro loses a lot of points for having a katana. On the other hand, Ed gains a few points for not needing to carry a sword. He just transmutes his arm into one whenever he wants to.

[Jackrabbit]

If we're going by how cool someone's sword is, Bro loses a lot of points for having a katana. On the other hand, Ed gains a few points for not needing to carry a sword. He just transmutes his arm into one whenever he wants to.

Problem: We're not going by how cool someone's sword is. We're going by who likes what more. Frankly, Ed could kill God from a mile away with harsh words alone and if people like Bro more, he's still going to win.

[Daywalkah]

I just remembered what Ed is from.

Ed FTW

[Criptfeind]

Ed can fence and can do alchemy.

And Bro can move so fast that you can not even see him. You point is?

[Leafsnail]

The swords in a museum near my house which are so huge noone can wield them effectively.

One day, someone will be able to use it perfectly.  They shall become ruler of the world.

[Criptfeind]

Until someone takes out their camera.

[CJ1145]

If we're going by how cool someone's sword is, Bro loses a lot of points for having a katana. On the other hand, Ed gains a few points for not needing to carry a sword. He just transmutes his arm into one whenever he wants to.

Problem: We're not going by how cool someone's sword is. We're going by who likes what more. Frankly, Ed could kill God from a mile away with harsh words alone and if people like Bro more, he's still going to win.

Now I'd have less a problem with your reasoning if he hadn't done essentially that.

Can we just have a quick tally of who is for and against a teamup? I am for.

[Diablous]

Against.

[Sensei]

No more teamups! Quite simply, bro is better.

[dragnar]

For. Because otherwise nothing will be able to stand up to the Curly/Sleuth teamup.

That is a folly to say that he will lose because he is so used to fighting people very weak and therefor will underestimate Ed. He did not loss because of that to Jack and Jack is much stronger then Ed.

Ah, but Ed appears to just be a little child, not really a challenge. Bro would make the mistake of thinking he'd be closer to Dave in strength, as opposed to Jack. Bro is more powerful than Ed, but so is pretty much every person Ed's ever fought, and he always comes out on top.

So your argument is that Bro will underestimate Ed (something you have no real reason to think.) and Eds plot protection will save him

Not really plot protection, Ed wins all of his fights simply because of quick surprise attacks when his opponents think he's beaten.

[RAM]

I'll post some unbiased reference pictures.

Edward Elric


Bro

[CJ1145]

Not really plot protection, Ed wins all of his fights simply because of quick surprise attacks when his opponents think he's beaten.

Seriously, the guy is a Determinator. He was stabbed through the torso and had a building collapsed on top of him, and that only pissed him off.

As for RAM's little editing fun, you've now convinced me Ed would win in a real fight, because Bro and Dave think Buster Swords suck, then go around swinging Sephiroth's obviously-not-phallic weapon.

[Heron TSG]

Didn't we already decide this was a popularity contest?

[Diablous]

As for RAM's little editing fun, you've now convinced me Ed would win in a real fight, because Bro and Dave think Buster Swords suck, then go around swinging Sephiroth's obviously-not-phallic weapon.

Despite what that fan art says, Bro's katana is not very long.