That made very little sense. We all have to make decisions for everyone? What if we don't like eachothers decisions?
No as in you make decisions for the kingdom as a whole.
I'm not sure how far you need to go to make it 'god modding'. It's not like we've got warriors with laser beams, yet. Besides, isn't the point of the GM (And execvtioner) to call out people who are gmodding?
True.
What if you just put a dot point with - 1. Construction complete on new stone wall at redship fief. Update map accordingly.
Note that I didn't really have a point here... I just want- yeah.
True.
This is why I put 'if you were lazy' at the start. Besides, God modding happens for two reasons. A. A player wants to cheat. B. A player gets his facts a little wrong. Rome wasn't built in a day, but there's got to be someone out there who honestly believes it took them two years. In any case. If we behead all alpha level godmodders, and berate beta-level godmodders, then that'd solve it. A well run forum game doesn't require too much work from the GM.
True.
Yes.
Thank you.
I can not really argue with you because I agree with what you are saying. On the other hand Barbarossa is the main GM and we need to leave the final say to him. Although I think I have a stone that will kill three birds with one toss. Here are four points for a way to handle this.
1: Barbarossa handles overreaching plots and kingdom wide events. These will be reactionary and proactive.
2: I make a list of fief level events and individual actions that are made by each fief. These will be reactionary unless Barbarossa or I think of something that needs to happen than can not be handled by point one.
2.1: Any ruling I make here are semifinal and you will not complain, you may ask that I or Barbarossa change them in this thread.
3: Any changes that need to be made will be made by the player or by me if I have time and than all changes will be PMed to me and I will merge them.
4: Any god modders or people who claim powers that are unfair will called out by ether me or Barbarossa, anyone and bring up a thing they think is abuse of power in this thread.
4.1:If you think you are not god moding you can ask Barbarossa in this thread to change the ruling, if he says no you can put it to a vote and if it gets past 60% you may ask Barbarossa again, anything past the first ruling is your responsibility though.
What do you guys think?