Day 2. Time to cut the silly and put on my gameface.
Theory: We were facing a cult (now ended), and still have a Serial Killer to deal with. Mechanically, the cult it is lead by a Devil, who indoctrinates others through Demonic possession, but cannot themselves kill. Any Demons they possess gain a Nightkill though. On N0, the Devil picks, or is assigned an initial Demon (probably to keep the game from ending in a D1 lynch). I'm inclined to think the starting Demon was chosen by Toaster, since Org has perpetual WIFOM that makes him iffy to kill.
Anyway, Demon Org views Leafsnail as a threatening player (as evidenced by the last Paranormal Mafia), so he targeted him on N1 with his Nightkill. On the same night, our Serial Killer was suspicious of Org's assuredness on D1 of there being a Cult, and went after him, hoping to eliminate Scum and help lower his chances of being NKed by them. Meanwhile, Devil Toaster sought to indoctrinate a player into the cult, and targeted a Sorcerer ("A powerful mage, the sorcerer likes to keep to himself and has the power to enforce his seclusion.") I take that to mean that the Sorcerer counterkills anyone targeting him... hence the steaming hole in Devil Toaster's torso, which goes clear into the floorboards.
I've not got the facts to substantiate this, but if you yourself have knowledge (were targetted by the Devil last night, etc) you can test the veracity of this yourself.
By my reckoning, we are looking at some sort of monstrous Serial Killer (namely one with claws). If I had to take my pick, my suspicions fall on Toonyman for his self-protective passive aggression.
Also, welcome brother Rysith! By all means, feel free to join the discussion post haste.