Welcome!
Since my question to Ottofar is out of date, I'll ask you this instead: Out of the current players, who would you most want to be on your team as scum? Who do you think would be hardest to read as scum?
(Still kinda RVSish when we're starting to move out of it, but I wanted to pick your brain. Plus, I'm sure you will be giving us your suspicions anyway. Right?)
Of course I'll give my suspicions. But first, your question. I would want either you or Lonewolf on my team as scum. You guys strike me as the more skilled players here. I would want the more skilled players to be either on my side or dead.
Now, for my suspicions. Hmm, I would say my top suspicions are
USEC_OFFICER and
Taco Dan.
USEC: Never changed his random vote at the start. Then lots of active lurking, never contributing much. When he finally gives "justification" to his vote, he said that Bandages was trying his hardest to prevent him getting lynched. I don't find someone trying not to die very scummy on it's own. Also, Bandages actions seems like someone calling out another player for leaving a reasonless random vote on him all game. USEC's response that he is trying to keep himself(Bandages) from getting lynched seems like him making shit up to justify his vote.
Taco: Does not seem to care about where his vote lies. Since their vote is the only weapon a townie has against the scum, a townie should care a lot more about where their vote goes. It would make sense for the scum to not care about their vote since they have the night kill. He also just resaid what Lonewolf has stated about USEC, and voted for USEC after Lonewolf. Not exactly the most subtle way to bandwagon. All in all, though, I consider USEC to be way more scummy than Taco.
pre post edit:
Yaknow what? Unvote
UESC_Officer what have you got against self-preservation, hmm? Trying to pin the scum on someone else, maybe? Making up scumtells is classic scum behavior.
Aaaaand Taco Dan - You voted USEC_OFFICER and the only reasons you gave are a rehash of my arguments. Not only a more subtle form of buddying, but also a fairly blatant act of bandwagoning. Explain yourself.
So just because I had the same reasons as you, and you just happened to post those reasons first, I'm supposed to make up new reasons? I don't think so.
Just restating what another says is buddying and bandwagoning, and is scummy. Expanding on it, putting in your opinions and thoughts is not scummy.